Reviews for Mama Mia's in Geneseo, NY
The worst pizza we?ve ever had. My husband and I waited almost an hour since it was super busy with a large group ahead of us... and it would have been fine had the pizza been somewhat good for the price! $21 for a large pizza that was about the size of amedium at best. it was so paper thin it fell apart before I could even get it out of the box. I had to eat the pizza piece bypiece with my fingers. the garlic on it was way too strong and had we not have to leave for a movie we would have asked for ourmoney back. Not sure if it was like this because it was so busy or if this is normal but it was so awful I felt the need tomention it here. Read more
Absolutely amazing experience, would 100% recommend!! The pizza was truly delicious, crunchy and cheesy as you like them. We... also had chicken salad with balsamic sauce which was really tasty. And we had cannolis for dessert, they are home and freshmade, just incredible, you cannot walk out without trying them out!! (Best ones tasted outside Italy) The staff was superfriendly, very generous, truly nice and professional! We were served very quickly, my parents were amazed about this restaurant,they really appreciated it! So, do not think twice, you can trust this place 100%! Read more
Loved it! The pizza was amazing! I'm not a fan of thin crust but the flavor was delicious! I will definitely eat there again. A... slice of cheese and pepperoni pizza 4$ can't beat that! Read more
Stopped in for a quick bite and so glad I did! The cheese ???? was hot, crispy and delicious. I wanted a cup of coffee and I was... given a freshly brewed carafe of awesome joe! Great find! Highly recommended! Read more
We had the grilled chicken Cesar salad and the antipasto salad. Both delicious. The regular slice was great and best of all was... the supreme slice. Pepperoni, sausage, meatball olives and onions. Wow. Really wasn't expecting much from a college town pizzaplace, but very well done by Mamma Mia. Nice job by the young man making the pies on the afternoon of 9/18/22. Read more
Came on Labor Day. Was not expecting a lot and was pleasantly surprised. Pizza is a solid NYC slice. Guy behind the counter... seemed like the only one working but was flying around the kitchen and running it like a pro. Read more
Pretty good. Had a nice of cheese... It was thin crust, crispy, crunchy and tasted good. Right amount of grease. Good flavor.... Great hangover slice. Read more
Great service. Great pizza. Good price. Will visit them again.