Reviews for Nolas Osteria and Pizza in Garwood, NJ
Let me just say this pizza is TO DIE FOR! Sooooo amazing. We found Nola?s by a friend?s recommendation and first ordered the... Warrior Pie. Delicious doesn?t begin to describe how good it was. Next time we opted for the Nonna Square which is theirversion of a grandma pie. I liked it better than the Warrior! I wished I took a picture of it. This last time we tried theTomato Pie as we want to sample each one. Also equally as delicious as the Warrior and Nonna Square! Let me add that I livewithin walking distance of four pizzerias and I will make the 20 minute drive for this pizza. It is THAT GOOD! Next on my listis the Grandpa and Alexa Pie. They also have a system for ordering where if you call early enough you can pick a time slot topick up your pie on the weekends which I recommend. They are a BYOB so my next visit will be dine in. Read more
Excellent pizza, lived up to the hype that I've been hearing. Had a Nonna's with mushrooms and a sausage pie. Both were... absolutely delicious. Thin crust, nice and crispy. Read more
So my husband and decided to see what all the hype was about. We went tonight and ordered a Nona's square with sausage. The... wait and the hype was all worth it! Our pie came out piping hot and it was thin and crispy just how we like it. The place waspacked and pies were flying out the door. The table next to us had pasta dinners that looked great. Mark, the owner, gave uscannoli zeppolies to take home. Soooo good! We will definitely go back and eat our way through the menu. Read more
Excellent pizza. Ingredients are super fresh and each bite packs a great deal of flavor. Crust is superb. Sauce if fresh and... home made. Cheese is delicious. Staff is great as well. Very friendly and proud of their pizza. Highly recommend this spot. BYOBso plan ahead. I would rate this an 8.4 on my pizza scale. Had the warrior pie and the drunken nona (square). Flavor on the Nonawas excellent but the warrior pie was just terrific. Crunchy, thin, and perfectly cooked. They make the pizza in a pan andfinish it off in the oven. Wish this place lots of luck and thank you for delivering such a tasty pie! Read more
It took a while, but I finally got myself to Nola?s and it was definitely worth the wait! Despite getting to the restaurant a... half hour before closing and staying a few minutes late, Marc and his staff happily sat us and spoke to us while dining. We hadthe Warrior Pie and without a doubt was one of if not the best round pies I?ve ever had. It?s a pan pie so the cheese goes allthe way to the edges developing a caramelized crust. Fresh mozzarella and a sweet plum pizza sauce just brought this pizza tothe next level. Marc, the owner, was kind enough to give us a side of hot honey, a special kind that is solely proprietary tothem, to drizzle on our slices!! Needless to say the honey was excellent and the pizza even more so. I will most definitelybe back!! Read more
Hands down the best pizza for miles, great spot. They're super busy because the food is so good, so be patient and plan your... order ahead of time, but absolutely worth it. We get some of everything, these are the Warrior pie, cheese bar pie, and DrunkenNonna pie (my favorite). Best pizza around! Read more
With so much good pizza available in NJ I normally won?t wait long for an order but Nolas is an exception. Incredible bar pies.... The Warrior bar pie might be my all time favorite thin crust pizza. The homemade potato chips are amazing as well. I hope theycan add more hours soon so that I can order during off peak hours. Read more
First time trying Nolas ???? We ordered the Nola Special which has meatballs on it, a cheese pan pie w/sausage & zeppole bombs w... cannoli cream. Both pies were absolutely delicious & cooked to perfection!! The Zeppole bombs were gone in seconds ???? Youcould definitely tell that all the ingredients were very fresh. Steve was very helpful & courteous when we ordered. We willdefinitely be back, this business cares about quality over quantity & knows how to treat their customers. 10 stars!!???????? ???????????????????? Read more