Reviews for Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant in Garnerville, NY
This place is Amazing , Chicken parmesan sliders are Good and not that crowded every week , always wanted to travel to Italy ,... Ciao ???????????????????? Read more
This place was good and it just gets worse and worse now ?if you ask for linguine they give you spaghetti??? And your name is... original Italian???? All of the pasta dishes especially the Alfredo is heavily watered down to the point where the sauce islike slop and tasteless this is from not straining the pasta or there sauces are just that bad?. The pizza is heavily packedwith extremely hardy marinara sauce ?something out of a can probably ?.. and delivery times are almost a hour every time nomatter what you order they say it?s because they have a high volume of deliveries ?. Ok so then hire more drivers????.. allaround bad experience Read more
I ordered a delivery at 7pm the young lady knew my address and repeated it back to me said it will arrive in 30 to 45 min. I... called back an hour and a half later and they said they don't do delivery after 8 and they don't have my order in the system. I will never order here again. Tired of the terrible service and inconsistent overpriced food. Read more
I firmly and specifically ordered a half chicken and a half plain pie. After returning home I found out from my son and my baby... nephew that we were given bacon. When we called the restaurant, they told me i was lying and I was confused which is NOT thecase because eating pork is totally against my religious beliefs! Unprofessional to accuse a customer of mistaking such adelicate order! Read more
Called to order food but I was unable to order. The person taking my order did not know what pasta was. She did not understand... pasta primavera and asked me to spell it. Needless to say we ordered elsewhere. We always order from here and never had thisproblem before today. Read more
I?m sorry but the rave reviews must come From people who have never had a NYC slice of pizza. I moved here and am still on a... quest to find a place that comes close to a Bronx slice. I ordered two garlic sliders and a slice of pizza. Pizza was verythin, not crispy and the sauce is super thick and tastes very low quality. The garlic sliders were mushy on the inside and cold.Why not make them to order? Bread was soggy, so was the chicken cutlet inside and the cheese was not melted. 21 dollars later- got my answer - never coming here again. You can tell when someone takes pride in making pizza as opposed to someone justthrowing it together. Read more
This place has some of the best pizza I?ve ever eaten. Pictured below is their equivalent to a Supreme Pizza (I believe they... call it Dumpster Pile, just know it comes with sardines) and it is glorious. Everything from their basic pepperoni/sausage pizzato this has always been perfect. Pricey, yes, but worth it. Read more
Food was good and they were open later than 9 which is a nice change for the area. A bit pricey at $5 a slice but the pizza was... good. Parking is available out front but a bit more light would be nice in the parking lot. Staff was friendly and helpful.Would visit again. Read more