Reviews for Santoni's Pizzeria and Restaurant in Garfield, NJ

I got disappointed with my Last order of chicken ?wings? or should I say ?Chicken NECKS?. ???? Update 11/11/2022: I?ve been a... customer for many year as a Garfield resident and I continued ordering Chicken wings even after my bad luck with my wing orders,but when I placed the order I added a note to remind them not to give necks. I don?t do this as a joke as one of the cashiersgot mad at me about the order note and my bad review. He told me that they are a Pizzeria and why I would keep ordering wings.So why are they selling chicken wings. If they sell chicken wings and it comes with necks they probably should add in the menuwings and necks. I would think when you order something from the menu you should receive what you order rather than some randomcombination of things. They could?ve replied to my review and fix the issue but they didn?t. It is bad that they treat thecustomers like that. Read more

The staff and the food are always amazing been going here since i was in HS . Definitely recommend

Love your food But I ordered a grilled chicken Parmesan no sauce very little very disappointing not that much cheese dry... sandwich so I got to say Read more

This is a good pizza restaurant. The only reason I give them four stars instead of five is because they're consistency is... occasionally lacking. That said, the pizza always tastes good and the staff is friendly. Read more

best pizza in the area! not sure why people on facebook are saying they are under new ownership, they definitely aren't.

I love trying new places out but Santonis will always be my preferred pizzeria. Always enjoyed the food and of course the pizza.... I ordered a jalapeno pizza, my personal preference I'd like it a bit spicier maybe more seeds? But that's just my own experienceand I still enjoyed it lots. Thanks for being around for so long and I hope even more years to come! Read more

I?ve always loved their pizza! So today we ordered pizza, and a sausage and pepper hero. Ladies and gentlemen, I must say that... the sausage and pepper hero was the absolute gold standard! In all my years eating this kind sandwich from all other places,this was the absolute BEST I?ve ever had. The meat which they did not skimp on was spread throughout the entire bread leaving nodry areas. And it was DELICIOUS! The ratio of meat and onions, peppers and sauce was perfect. The bread never felt soaked or todry. I had to call them right after I finished the hero to let them know! 5 stars is not enough for this amazing restaurant!! Read more

Ordered two pizza pies, a grandma with extra sauce and crispy and another being a vegetable pizza. Both tasted great my... favorite was def the grandma because of the sauce distinct flavor and chunky plum tomatoes ????. As for the vegetables pizza itis very limited in choices which I did mention to gentlemen on the front desk (AWSOME guy, very welcoming and kind). I choseolives, green peppers, jalapeño, mushrooms ???? and extra sauce. Pizza topping they were not cheap with the veggies for sure ($2 per topping). I do recommend them adding maybe more veggie options and cheese to on top of the veggies. Very good crisp onboth. I definitely would order again. Grandma ???? for sure. Great guys there. Will come back. Good for family pizza and largegatherings. I attached a pic so you guys can see for yourselves. P.a red flakes are necessary to spice things up! And a littleoregano. Read more