Reviews for Yellowstone Pizza Company in Gardiner, MT
This is the Mammoth pizza it's as thin as cardboard it's $24.95 No one waits on you, you stand in line to order and then they... add 10% automatically to your total. The pizza was edible was expecting something more especially for the price and would havebeen nice to had a traditional pizza not super thin crust. And beer is almost $7.00 for one bottle of domestic!!!. Out of themany places we have eaten here in Montana this was the only disappointing one. Read more
Dough has no option only thin pre made. 8 inch pizza is from $28. Service charge comes for self -serve. It is for tourists only.
This should be illegal. 26 dollars for an okay pizza that was barely enough to fill me and my friend after our 800 dollar tour... in the park. After buying 2 fountain sodas and a 3 dollar tip it came to 40 dollars. How does that even work. Very sad! Start tothe season. Imagine trying to feed a wife and 3 kids, you would be spending 200 dollars here. Read more
Goods- The taste of pizza was nice. We got the Yellowstone and Narcissus pizza. Thin & crispy crust. Friendly... staff. Opportunities- Very pricey. $19 for the veg and $24 for the bison & elk ground pizza. Very light (&thin)pizza. Compulsory 10% gratuity regardless of anything. Their phone does not work. Read more
Unfortunately, they did not have sufficient staff to allow indoor dining and were overwhelmed by the demand. We ate our pizza on... the sidewalk, alongside other hungry travelers. I thought the gluten free crust was good; my non-GF family was not impressed.Still the best option we could find around. Read more
Just ok if you're at Yellowstone and *need* food. Otherwise, skip it. The crust is SUPER thick and there's not enough sauce and... cheese. No lie, the crust is at least 0.5 inch thick. Honestly, my first thought biting into this was that it tasted like thefrozen pizza I had in my childhood. Crust to sauce ratio is off. For context, I'm from NYC and love thin pizza with a healthyhelping of tomato sauce and gooey melted cheese. This place just didn't do it for me. If you end up here, the Hell Roaring(spicy Canadian bacon) was the best one. The Hayden Valley and Soda Butte were too dry and not generous with the elk and bison. Read more
First off the pizza is excellent! 5 stars all the way. Authentic Italian pizza with thin crust that is some of the best we have... tried anywhere. Pricing is nothing unusual for the area. Drink selection ard Pepsi products and no alcohol is served. Now forthe 3 stars. Not sure if it's lack of help or bad management, but overhearing other families waiting on their food for 30minutes to an hour is not okay. Our order was to the table within 20 minutes while we saw tables with customers who alreadyordered only have drinks. A few upset customers fuming mad... Roll Tide from Alabama!! Read more
Would never return to this restaurant. Spent $32 for a personally sized pizza and a side salad. They charge u for using a card... but they are card only. No cash accepted. They also automatically charge a 10% tip and ask for a tip on top of that!! They onlyserve pizza and a side salad. No pasta or wings. The staff was highly unpleasant and the pizza was flat as cardboard. Sodisappointed and would discourage everyone from giving this place their hard earned money. Read more