Reviews for Calogero's in Garden City, NY
Big Family dinner the night before the wedding. The Staff and Owner stuck with us as we overstayed our visit but tallied up food... and continous beverages so they didn't mind too much. A great atmosphere. Excellent food from a varied menu. Go there. Read more
From the food, the atmosphere, to the service- Calogero's did an exceptional job making my baby shower special. Luke and all the... staff were extremely accommodating with any question or request. Thanks to the staff for an amazing day. Read more
This restaurant is an amazing place, and I had gone for a dinner date with my girlfriend, and it was amazing food, amazing... service...and the wait staff are very accommodating. Even when I was running late, I let the restaurant know and the folks overthe phone were understanding! 11/10 must eat here! Read more
Small portions and a little high priced. Nice outdoor seating makes it nice. Food is good quality just need more on $30... plates 2 adults 2 children was over $150 Read more
I must say I was extremely happy with the food and service that was provided at my daughter's baby sprinkle. It was a last... minute event as she lives out of state. They were all accommodating with the menu, décor and even opened the restaurantearlier so that all the decorators were able to take their time and make it look beautiful. I am so happy I was able to holdthe event here and would recommend it to anyone looking to have a party. Read more
Can I just say that choosing Calageros for our wedding shower was a fantastic choice! The outside tent was beautiful. It was... very nicely decorated with hanging floral decor and wreaths. The waiting staff gave us five service the entire time. Thesangria is delicious and fresh. The food is also outstanding, very fresh and full of flavor. We will definitely return at somepoint in the future! Read more
One of my favorite restaurants ever! 5 stars doesn't do them justice. Delicious and amazing food, awesome service and ample... parking. Just had a dinner party there in their private space. Not only was the food perfectly made but our waiter was soattentive. They took safety precautions seriously and was very hygienic (cleaned/sanitized) the high chairs, used Napkins tohand straws/utensils before giving to us.. Ronnie the manager is always accommodating and so easy to work with. Read more
Excellent food choices. Monk fish was cooked to perfection. Very nice dinning experience. Service was fast and... attentive. Highly recommended. Read more