Reviews for Manhattan Chicago Pizza Gainesville in Gainesville, GA

I don't come here often enough. The NY pizza, is NYC style. I haven't tried the Chicago yet. The lasagna. Large portion that... includes a small salad and 3 garlic knots is very good both taste and value. Read more

First time customer. I ordered a Liberty NY pizza and a Empire Calzone and cheese sticks on Thursday night Nov 10th My husband... and I did enjoy the food and the prices seemed normal and not inflated. It was cooked just fine and the ingredients tasted goodand the two gentlemen who took care of my order even double checked on me personally asking if I was okay and everything as Istarted to leave because they noticed I was grieving and going through something personal. Read more

Delicious food and great service! We got a deep dish pizza and it was good, with really flavorful sauce but the real winner was... the calzone with ham (Empire State, I think). Plenty of garlic in both which we loved. Can?t wait to return and try some moremenu items. Read more

We live super close and love to support local businesses so we drove over. There's no dining room, so no big deal, we'll get it... to go. The 2 person staff was in disarray. We get our 2 pasta dishes and the Alfredo sauce is so runny that it escapes thecontainer and runs out onto the car seat and my clothes. Not terribly though so the guy at the counter gives me some papertowels to clean it up and apologizes. We also realized they failed to give us the included salads and garlic knots. So, we askfor them and after a few minutes we took it all home. The spinach fettuccine Alfredo was like a soup with 5 quater size piecesof spinach. The "baked" ziti was noodles in a cheese marinara sauce and far from baked. The garlic knots, while edible, werechewy and tough. The salad was acceptable. We won't be going back to try their pizza, in fact, based on my broef view of theiroperation I can't imagine they will be in business much longer if they depend on return customers. This is a picture of theirmenu with their sharpie edits, not mine. Read more

Ordered a deep dish amd a NY style cheese pizza amd some wings. The reception I received upon entering the store was lackluster... at best. The girl couldn't even smile and was condensing. The wings had none of the options I wanted, buffalo with blue cheeseand ranch. The pizza was good but the experience has much to be desired. Good potential but needs alot of improvement. Read more

Horrible customer service! We ordered through Uber and both calzones were raw. The dough was raw around the edge and the under... part. I called and explained what happened and they asked me what did I want them to do? They called the manager and came backand said that I needed to call Uber because this matter was out of their control. When I told her Uber did their part right andraw food wasn?t Ubers responsibility someone else came to the phone and very rudely asked what I wanted. I told her we weretheir customers and hope they could give us credit or correct the situation but they insisted fir me to call Uber. When I toldher they lost us as customers and I would spread the word, she said ?okay, have fun with that?. Will never order anything fromhere again! Read more

The food is always fresh and delicious, the prices are very reasonable and the service is always friendly. I would recommend... this place to anyone looking for a good meal at a great price! Read more

Great deep dish, Chicago style pizza- SO thick and gooey. This is really heavy, really filling stuff. Four stars because I... grabbed my to-go order and went home only to realize at the house that they?d given me someone elses?s order. Also the ?Caesar?salad I purchased was just iceberg lettuce with some Parmesan cheese and croutons. Pretty mid. Read more