Reviews for Red Baron Pizza in Fulton, NY
This was our first visit to Red Baron. A friend had mentioned that they have really good meatball subs so we decided we wanted... to try it. But we were also interested in trying other stuff. So we also got a small Reuben Pizza and a large Meat Lovers withmushrooms. Meatball sub is good the only thing I would mention is a large has for me balls really should have six. As for theRuben Pizza it was excellent. Meat lovers Pizza I give it a seven out of 10. Decent amount of toppings and a good amount ofcheese. Overall good place to eat. Read more
Food is great here, my only critique is of their garlic parm wings, they don't really taste like garlic or parm and they need... more salt. 9/10 would definetly recommend Read more
Great chicken salads, pizza subs and chicken tenders. Everything is hot and cooked to perfection when delivered and when picked... up. If there is an issue they always resolve it. I recommend Red Baron. Best food in town! Read more
Pizza tastes on par with High School cafeteria pizza. I've had better pizza in Scranton. 2.25 a slice is too much for pre-made... dough with some tomato sauce and cheese dropped on top. How???? Read more
I got the large pizza and 1.5 lb boneless wings special. Also got a ham and cheese sub. Boneless wings were great, hot sauce... is perfect heat with excellent flavor. Pizza is mediocre. Pre made crusts are so so. I prefer dough made fresh in store. Subwas excellent. Overall not too bad and decently priced. Read more
Went to Red Baron for the first time in years. It was so disappointing! It cost us $55 for a large pepperoni pizza and 20 wings.... We asked for the wings to be extra crispy and there was no crisp at all. They were slimy and fatty. Never going there again! Read more
Honestly was a little disappointed in the quality of the pizza but I'd imagine being from the Philly area good pizza is a norm.... The pizza was thick, sweet and had a lot of cheese. Absolutely not thin crust. The pizza was also smaller then I was expectingfor a large. The toppings were under a layer of cheese so at first glance it looked like a plain pizza. There wasn't much ofthem anyway. It's not the worst we've ever had but not the best. Was disappointed to see across the street is a restaurant withBrick Oven Pizza New York Style with take out. Exactly what we wanted but didn't show up in the search. The wings were fresh andgood. I asked for a large fry and I got very large thick fries but not many. Maybe lost in translation I don't know. Not worththe almost $40 for a large pizza, fries and 10 wings. Read more
First time there, was going to dine in but kinda small, 3 tables. Was very clean though. Decided to take home. 4 stars on... atmosphere because it was small. Ordered a small Reuben pizza, a large meat lovers pizza and meatball sub to really get a tasteof the place. The whole order took 15 minutes, which was quick, placing the order to them bringing it to the counter. I have tosay that the pizzas and sub were amazing. We can't wait to try other pizza varieties. Read more