Reviews for Elroy's Deli Market in Fremont, OH
I ordered subs for my work crew and I one day, needless to say they aren?t subs just oversized sandwiches. They look good but... it?s a sandwich not a sub, feel robbed Read more
We had a recent unfortunate experience. When picking up our order, we were told we needed a coupon for the pizza/cheesy bread... special (never needed one before, and we order often). Staff was unable to tell us how to get said coupon. The pizza weordered had toppings not listed on the menu description. A call to the manager wasn?t helpful. Although we really like thepizza at Elroy, we?ll be taking a break for a while. Very disappointing. Read more
6/10 Typically, it?s pretty good in my opinion. But, when you order an item so many times and then randomly one of the times it... gets made wrong it?s annoying. Point being, I ordered a Cuban pork sandwich, that comes with pulled slow cooked pork, love it.Got it many times, I get it today and it is FULL of DELI slices of HAM. And maybe a BITE of the roasted pork. I call to ask, andam told that?s how they now make them. With pork and ham. It?s not on their online menu like that. I know pork is pork but deliham is highly processed and is not even close to the same thing as pulled pork. Honestly disappointing. I?ve had the same thinghappen with pizzas. 95% sure it usually happens because of whoever is making it, either lack of caring or too muchexperimentation. Would be nice if things were more consistent. The foods good when it?s good but boy is it bad when it?s bad.And to be told I?m wrong about what?s on the sandwich when I?ve both ordered it a few times already and there?s a cleardescription of the sandwich on their website . Read more
The Carol Brie sandwich was unusual and delicious and my husband said his gyro was the best he ever had.
Elroy's Deli offer's so much on their menu. Really is a place that has something for everyone. I ordered a Greek Goddess Salad... and a chocolate cheesecake for dessert. I chose a half pound, and it was more than I thought it'd be. The cheesecake isheavenly, seriously so good. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, plenty of seating room, and it was very clean. Staff were veryfriendly and helpful, really took the time to share their personal favorites. They also have shelves set up with a niceselection of groceries and wine. Most things are not available in a regular grocery store. I'm trying the pasta next time. Read more
Since opening it has gone downhill. The place is enough to get by kind of clean. Food was cold, and hair was in two of the four... dishes purchased. Staff used no gloves, and picked pieces of food off of the racks sitting in kitchen. Was given a refund butwill not return. Read more
I'm often very skeptical of places that try to do too much or places that have too large a menu. When I saw that this place had... pizza and was also hailing itself as a deli I was a bit concerned. I ended up pleasantly surprised. The deli side is exactly asit should be; generous portions of good quality meats in classic deli sandwiches for prices that you would expect from a deli(not a bistro that's trying to serve deli foods at inflated prices). I got three full sandwiches, a pizza and cheese bread for$40. The pizza side of things is actually surprisingly good too. Is it the best pizza I've ever had? no, but did it exceedmy expectations for pizza at a deli absolutely. This place is doing the amount of menu items that they need to survive whilestill not trying things they can't pull off. You end up with is a very solid deli experience that has the bonus of makingdecent pizza. At some point I suppose I became somewhat of a takeout food pessimist and have begun to expect places to overpromise and under deliver. This was a nice exception and delivered exactly what it promised for a price point that was veryreasonable. I will certainly use this as one of my go-to "I'm hungry and I don't know what I want" options in Fremont. Read more
As far as I'm concerned this was the best place I've eaten at thus far and I've been in Florida for two weeks definitely have to... go back before I leave Read more