Reviews for Tonys N.Y. Pizza in Fort Myers, FL
Our experience was great! From the mommy we walked in to the time we got our food!!!! Our kids are now wishing we had one of... these locations in St.Louis!! From the plentiful toppings to the cooked to perfection crust!!!! They definitely don?t just hireanyone to cook & you can tell! We ordered an 18in 1/2 Bronx 1/2 cheese! It was the perfect size for a family of 4 & the pricepoint is awesome! They also sell by the slice if want to try a bit of everything ???? Read more
DELICIOUS!!!! One of the best NY style pizzas (without visiting NY) around! Tony's rocks a variety of different pizzas with... catchy names! From the "Bronx" (which I had) to the traditional deep dish Sicilian, there are plenty of pizzas options to choosefrom. The serving staff is pleasant and fast! You can pick from just a single (HUGE) slice to a whole pie. Eat in or carry out,you won't regret either choice! Read more
Amazing!! The pizza was so tasty, and 1 slice was enough to fill me up, but it's worth it to buy the whole pie so you can have... some for home! My husband had a calzone and it was HUGE and filled to the brim! He said he will never order one from anywhere! We will definitely be coming back... Read more
Not an Italian foodie but they served beer ????. Tried the Stromboli and with the sauce on the side it was fantastic. The... service great. Ask for Lauren she was quick and friendly. Read more
My first visit was a good one. The pizza was worthy of the "New York" part of it. I grew up in the Bronx and the best pizza was... made at Tony's on Bedford Park (no relation that I know of). The restaurant was good, with plenty of seating, but not enoughbased on the lunch crowd. They have fountain soda, bottled soda and beer! Parking is ample and the location is convenient. Thestaff was friendly. Sorry about the half eaten pizza, but I wanted to show the nice sausage. Read more
This place is definitely a 3.5 stars if not some more. The service is always good, the food fresh and the servers attentive and... knowledgeable about the menu. The actual place is a little crowded but clean? even the bathrooms!! And that?s rare for a placethat is so crowded. Go hungry ???? and expect the food to be yummy ????. #enjoy and the rest will be pizza history ????. We hadthe 14? Manhattan pizza with hot chicken wings and left there more than stuffed with a box of leftovers. It was definitely worththe $$. Hope you #enjoy it!! Read more
Just moved to the neighborhood from Arizona and giving all local restaurants a chance! Let me tell you, This one hit a home run!... Was greated by Scott with a smile and made me feel welcomed! Explained what it is they offer as I told him I was newbie! Iexpressed I was looking for a beer, he said yes we have some there in a cooler, he then answered all my questions about thepizza and the process. I then sat down after ordering a slice of the Staten Island and the Manhattan and asked for a local beer.They had Fort Myers Brewery High 5 IPA! I always support local businesses! Great IPA BTW Let me tell you people, not only was Igreeted by Scott, I was then greeted by a sweet waitress by the name of Danielle she took it from there! Very nice, informativemade me feel appreciated that I was there. Now the food, "IT WAS AMAZING!" I'm a huge fan of thin crispy crust with freshtoppings, this place delivered. I can't wait to take my wife and show her what they have to offer. She's a huge fan of bruchettaand from what I saw she's not going to be disappointed! Look forward to supporting my local busines again real soon! See you allthere!!!! Read more
If I could give a rate below zero I would. Called to tell these "employees " that my pizza was burnt (via picture) they said... they didn't believe me and I had to bring it back. Awful costumer service. Pizza tastes like box pizza, even when it's notburnt. Said employee hung up on me. The professionalism is super low. Was told " the manager is cooking and can't come to thephone. " would never recommend and in fact will do the opposite. You need knew employees. Read more