Reviews for Poppy's Pizza in Fort Myers, FL
Normally great but tonight the delivery pizza was burnt. I called and told them that it was burnt. Response was apologetic but... that was it. Read more
I always come here when I'm on vacation in SW Fl! It's one of must go to places when visiting! Everything has always been spot... on! Definitely NY pizza. I will say the Calzone is one of the best I've ever had. Even the wings are really good! And theyalways remember me when I come visit! It's so laid back and relaxing like going to a freinds house! Read more
Slow service, only ok pizza. We seemed to be getting served our drinks by a regular customer or maybe someone who worked there... but was officially not on shift due to a seeming lack of staff. I appreciate their help but this isn't the way to run arestaurant. I'm sure the one guy who seemed to be waiting was having a busy night but it meant we waited a long time and when wedid get our pizzas they were going cold and not amazing. Will probably give them another chance but it would have to be a lotbetter next time. Read more
This is the kind of post I like to write. We rolled into Ft Myers on Friday night and went to our favorite local brewery, Point... Ybel, en route to Sanibel. We wanted pizza after a few beers so hit up Google and found this gem of a place. We got a large?Godfather? and it was one of the best pizzas I?ve had in ages. Strangely enough, I was NOT hooked at first bite, disliking themhoney glaze at first, but by bite three it totally started to ?work? on my palate, with the mild hungry taste cutting throughall the fatty, saltiness of the more traditional pizza ingredients. If I ever find myself in the Fort Myers area again, I wouldcertainly relish the chance to return to this place. Yes, prices are high by southern US standards but coming from Miami, it wasactually a bargain for us! Great NY style crust. Good thing I?m returning to Sanibel in a few days?. Read more
We?ve been twice just this week as we really liked their pizza! Toppings were fresh (no canned mushrooms or mushy tomato chunks)... and we liked how the crust wasn?t thick and was just done to the right amount of chewy. Enjoyed the staff and they had goodwine and beer options. When we return to FM in a few weeks, we will try some of their other dishes. Read more
Horrible experience. When my Pizza showed up, all the toppings had slid off. When we called them they told us it?s because of... the tomatoes and wouldn?t do anything for us. The crust was burnt and the toppings were very cold. Sad because it wasn?t oversauced or over cheesy like most places. Will not order again. Read more
Had another great meal at Poppy's! What drew us here initially was the additions of our favorite gnocchi in a divine gorganzola... sauce and the best lasagna from Yabo Chef. But we also discovered the excellent pizza by Poppy and bringing one home. Theyreheat to a crispy crust, yum. I had the really well presented salmon with mushrooms, asparagus, tomatoes in a beautiful sauceover the creamy parmigiana risotto. Hubby had the lasagna. To top it off we split the light and sweet tiramasu. Again, notdisappointed with a single thing. Read more
Great pizza, excellent service and great owner. Currently cash only until their internet is restored. Help them out post Ian and... buy a pizza. Read more