Reviews for McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos in Fort Myers, FL

BEST PIZZA IN LEE COUNTY! NO, seriously! I'm an Italian guy who loves checking out local pizzerias. I have to say when I first... tried McGregor pizza I was in awe with how delicious their pizza was. It definitely reminds you of a NY style pizza . Also therestaurant interior is very nice an modern style with pieces of Italy incorporated in the decor. The daily specials are prettygreat! Been to both McGregor locations a handful of times and won't stop! Always telling friends & family to get McGregor'severy time they mention pizza. Owner is a great guy who loves to get to know his regulars Read more

We purchased two Stromboli?s for takeout. I had ham,mushroom and bacon in mine and my man got the veggie Stromboli with... meatballs. My fiancé? said it was the best Stromboli he?s ever had. Very tasty!! Staff was very friendly and helpful. Thank youfor one of the best restaurant experiences I?ve had since moving down here a year and a half ago. We will definitely be back! Read more

Great New York style pizza with a lot of options to choose from. The food is just as good as their original location. Owners... are very nice and welcoming. This is a much needed, positive addition to our area. Read more

Stopped here for some food randomly and I am so glad we did. Food was incredible, and I have high standards being from NY! The... bathroom was a good laugh and the staff were beyond friendly and helpful. Will be back!!!! (My only complaint is those metalchairs are beautiful but a bit uncomfortable!) Read more

Listen up! The pizza here was delicious! We ordered 4 large pizzas: the White, Green and Red along with a Summerlin Supreme, a... Pepperoni and Sausage combo, and a cheese. Plus the bathroom has amazing art that has to be seen. We shall return for asequel, no doubt. Read more

I do not typically post reviews after eating from somewhere once but this one really deserves it. I moved to San Carlos park... from Naples and have been let down time and time again by all the closest pizza places. We have tried at least 5 differentplaces if not more. Burnt, covered in flour, off taste. You name it.. I expressed how excited I was to try the pizza and had noidea they were there only to find out they just recently opened this location a few weeks ago (I haven?t been missing out forlong) the guy at the front told me I would not be disappointed and HE WAS NOT WRONG! I am so happy to have found a place thatactually knows how to make a good pizza and it?s only 3 minutes from my house. Read more

We ordered from the new location in San Carlos Park. We will definitely be back! It?s hard to find pizza that our 3 kids eat and... that meets the standards of myself and my husband, but this place did it! We cannot wait to order again and try more than justthe pizza! 5 stars all day long! Read more

First time trying and will definitely be back! Pizza tasted fresh, it wasn?t super greasy and had the perfect crispy, golden... brown bottom. We got the bianca pizza with pepperoni and the authentic with pepperoni! Best pizza we?ve had around San Carlosarea. Read more