Reviews for Il Pomodoro Italian Restaurant in Fort Myers, FL
Great dining experience! My spouse is a RI native, and she knows Italian cuisine. These guys do it right! the fish Francese... was superb; the baby clams and linguine was the best I've ever had. Service was great -- ask for Ian. Family restaurant doingit right! UPDATE: Second visit was just as good! Veal Francese and merlot perfect. Kate was a great server! Read more
I love good Italian food. We had a fantastic dinner here yesterday; it checked all the boxes. We came for the mussels. They... were awesome. Everything else was just the icing on the cake. All three of us loved our meals and can't wait to go back. Youshould make reservations. It fills up quickly. We were able to make same day reservations, but probably would have missed out ifwe just had shown up. Read more
I don't know how their food is because they don't keep the hours posted on their door. On a Friday night we went there at 8:20,... the door says they stay open till 9:00, but they were closed. I've been in food service all my life and I do not go intorestaurants right before closing and expect to get served, this is out of respect. But we were there 40 minutes before theirposted closing time, that's not good business. And again it was a Friday night! Read more
Just not good food for the price. The lasagna had to much fetta sheese and not enough pasta, the chicken marsela was to watery.... I'd be shocked if the pasta was made from scratch. The soup was terrible beans and pasta was lame. Cesar salid w no crutons andpinking edge lettice. For 48 bucks to go just not worth it. ???? ... Read more
Absolutely amazing! My family and I went here for dinner. No wait. Super friendly staff and amazing food. I got the rigatoni... bolognese which was incredible! Everyone at my table loved the food! Read more
As a family we came to Il Pomodoro Restaurant for the first time to celebrate a birthday and we were blown away with the... phenomenal service from our server Mary and manager Randy. The food was amazing and I would absolutely be back to try more ofthe delicious dishes on the menu. Thank you Mary and Randy! See you again soon. ???????????????? Read more
Did takeout.. The Margherita pizza I had was a cheap imitation of a true NYC style Italian pizza. Crust was Burned on the bottom... and undercooked on top. Ingredients not as fresh. The meatballs were akin to frozen store-bought meatballs. Needless to say thisorder didn't live up to tastebud potential and if you visit NYC or Italy-you can taste the difference for yourself. Severalother local restaurants have better food quality and kitchen talent. I can't speak to the pasta dishes, but the former wasmediocre at best. Read more
It was really surprising. I had ordered a sausage sandwich and I was expecting the standard fare. Sausage and mushrooms a few... peppers on a hoagie roll. That is not what I got. It was quite a generous portion I ended up having to take half of it home. Ireally like the atmosphere It's not a huge dining room so it's intimate I can't wait to go back with the wife. Update8/25/2022 Wife and I just had dinner and it was a wonderful experience. Everything from the drinks, to the desert was beyondour expectations. Wife was over the moon about Alfredo, and the tiramisu. This was the perfect place for a date nightdinner. Update 11/23/2022 Another wonderful meal. Love that I can take my wife out, it's a perfect place for a cozy evening. Read more