Reviews for Burntwood Tavern in Fort Myers, FL

Extremely disappointed with our experience tonight. Our food came out incorrectly, the Mahi-mahi was so fishy, and the flatbread... had no flavor and was soggy. The rest of the food was also very underwhelming. In addition, our server was not responsive to thelack of food eaten off our plates. We did bring up our unhappiness and the flatbread was taken off our bill. 2 stars onlybecause the drinks were good. Read more

Went for a large group event. We were set up outside seating. Not enough chairs at the beginning but they got everyone seated... for dinner. Kudos to the staff. They were attentive and made sure everyone was taken care of. The food was good. I really liketheir appetizers. I like their location in the Bell Tower Shopping Center. Read more

First time at Burntwood Tavern and you have to go! It’s the nicest spot with amazing food. The service received was so amazing... and I will definitely be back again. Read more

Wonderful place!! I definitely will be coming back. The atmosphere is comfortable and casual. The service is a bit slow at the... beginning but done properly. Now the food I have to say is the reason to come back. It taste so good and tasty that you justhave to try it yourself. Would recommend others to try!! Read more

Just ok and way overpriced food, super slow kitchen. Granted there were nine of us at lunchtime but we didn't sit down until... 1:15. Two of the three appetizers we ordered were extremely mediocre: tavern tater tots were doughy deep fried breading balls.Period. Margherita flatbread was tasteless. Then the wait started for our meals: salads and sandwiches, no entrees. 45 minuteslater out they came (The restaurant was practically empty by then so it's not like the kitchen was swamped). The burgers,sandwiches, and salads were o.k. The lobster bisque with chopped shrimp on top (?) two people reported it should have beencalled cheddar cheese soup with tablespoon of chopped shrimp on top. Neither of them ate more than a few spoonfuls of the soup.My 1/2 California Chicken sandwich and house salad was just o.k. See the pic of the one lettuce clump on it and the tiny shmearof avocado. The house salad of shredded lettuce, etc. was drowning in dressing to the point the whole salad was soggy. Goodthing sandwiches came with fries because as a side dish the small single serving basket of fries would have been $7! 1 hour and40 minutes later we were out of there, and I, for one, will not return. Read more

My husband and I recently went to Burntwood Tavern to celebrate my birthday! We had such a great experience, the service was... amazing! Our server was professional, attentive and charismatic! The manager came over and checked in with us as well and shewas great! The food and drinks were also worth mentioning! We loved everything about this place 10/10! Will be back! Read more

This is the 4th time I've eaten here. I've never had a bad experience yet. It's very dog friendly which is a plus. I had the... tater tot appetizer which was amazing! My favorite thing so far is the wedge salad And the house cheeseburger Burger isunbelievably good! In the words of Arnold Schwarzenegger are in The Terminator! I will be back! Read more

They need to work on their to-go service. I’m giving them three stars only because they didn’t bother to read the ticket,... everything I said not to put on the entrées, they still put on the entrées. They also did not include the side salad that wewere charged extra for. As far as the fries go, I would say out of both of the boxes, 10% were edible. Read more