Reviews for Marchitelli's Cucina Italiana in Fort Collins, CO

Pasta was good and my husband LOVED his tiramisu but the service was really lacking. I’m not the type of person that thinks... people, particularly those in the service industry, need to go above and beyond in niceties. It was however, frustrating to notreceive service because the waitress was actively working on homework at the bar. I was super disappointed in the crèmebrûlée. The custard was hot and tasted like scrambled eggs. My husband had to go up to all the staff on their laptops at thebar to get help. Food was great, desert was gross, and service was subpar. Probably won’t be returning Read more

The wife and I went here recently to try a new Italian restaurant in town. We ordered a few appetizers to start out to try a... selection of their food. My wife ordered the Tomato Basil Bruschetta which was absolutely delicious. Every part of it wasperfectly paired. I went with their Ceasar salad which I thought would've been smaller, but I was mistaken! It was huge anddelicious. I'm not normally a fan of croutons, but the ones in this salad were exceptional! For the main course, I ordered theSicilian Seafood Pasta and the wife went with the Chicken Marsala. I don't think I've ever ordered a seafood pasta fromsomewhere and received so much seafood in the dish. They definitely do not skimp. Between the scallops, muscles, clams andshrimp all beinf perfectly cooked and paired with the spicy red sauce, it was all exquisite. As for my wives Chicken Marsala,she said it was absolutely phenomenal and couldn't stop raving about how good it was. Overall, I would highly recommendMarchitellis to anyone looking for incredible Italian food paired with some amazing servers and staff. Read more

We had a wonderful meal here tonight! Starting off with a garden salad with a homemade red pepper dressing served with bread... with an herbed butter that was tasty! Our table samples the White clam sauce with pasta, Chicken Marsala, Chicken Piccata,Chicken Florentine and gnocchi with sun dried tomato pesto and we all really enjoyed our meals. They service was excellent eventhough we came in at 9 just an hour before close. We will definitely return! Read more

Authentic and delicious italian food. The seafood pasta dish was especially created for me by the Chef due to red sauce causes... me terrible heartburn. It was AMAZING. All food and service was excellent. Cannot wait to eat there again! Read more

Service was excellent here. I had the chicken Marsala. The chicken was dry, an especially excellent feat considering it is... bathed in a delicious sauce. The garlic parmesan was delicious and would recommend giving it a try. Quiet place with nicedecor making it a good date night spot. Read more

Food and service was very mediocre. It was not busy at all. We didn't get the free bread for a long time after we placed our... order. When we finally got the bread it was cold. For very expensive entree's it was very disappointing. Entree's do not comewith a salad or soup. The red sauce was very watery. Fettuccine Alfredo came with a very small portion of chicken for the $6extra charge. We enjoy Nick's, Carrabba's, or oregano's much more. Both of us thought the price was not reflective of thequality. Chicken marsala- $25 Chicken fettuccine - $24 Creme brulee - $8 Read more

The best Marsala I have eaten in a restaurant! The special was the Steak Marsala and it was amazing. My wife had the traditional... Lasagna and loved it. The portions were large so we took some home, including the delicious warm bread with garlic butter. Wehad bread with our tasty Calamari appetizer, and with dinner. The owner came out to see how we enjoyed the meal, which was anice touch. Too bad he is only there a couple times a week. We topped it off with a very nice Creme Brûlée; just the rightamount of sweet and salty. Read more

Our first time trying out this new Italian restaurant in Ft Collins. Our server was Kelly and she was great. I had the Chicken... Piccata, which was excellent! My other family members ordered Sicilian seafood pasta and veal marsala. They said their disheswere fabulous as well! Thanks so much for great food and service! We’ll be back! Read more