Reviews for Gib's New York Bagels in Fort Collins, CO
They used to have big bagel knots but when we went there was only bagel bites which was disappointing ???? then we ordered six... bagels to go and they became dried out and hard by the end of the day which was more disappointing. The bites were really goodthough and so was my husband's breakfast sandwich which is why I rated it three stars. This location has been there since I wasin high school which was 20 years ago so that says something I'm sure, but it just wasn't what I remembered or was expecting.Disappointing for sure Read more
I love Gibs and wish that I could give it 5 stars but it has to be said that if you have any specifics about your order you can... count on it being messed up. I frequent Gibs and their food is good but 4 out of 5 times that I go they put tomatoes on my orderwhen I?m clear about not wanting them. This doesn?t change no matter which location I go to. I also like to get an Avalanchewith no coffee which is listed on the menu and every time I do the employees get very confused and sometimes just make me thedrink with coffee in it anyways. Again, I love Gibs and still continue to go but it has to be said they are not consistent aboutmaking sure their orders are accurate literally ever. Read more
I love this place and order at least once every 2 weeks: todays orders was not well put together ; requests incorrect ie: double... toasted , extra cheese. I?ll go again but maybe to another store?? disappointed as I expected consistent quality . Read more
The bagels are always good but the online ordering here is more inconvenient than just going in and waiting. The bagels normally... come out one time but the drinks take forever, as in they don?t even know you ordered one. This has been a consistent issuewhenever I order here. Read more
Here?s the thing, I love the taste of the bagels and continue to come back, but every time I order a bagel (and I get the same... kind every time) they give me one with a massive hole in it. yes, bagels do have holes obviously, but I?m talking no bagel evenleft type of hole. I think quality needs to be monitored a little heavier here. Read more
I hate to do it, but I can truly only give Gib's Bagels three stars. Their bagel quality is "meh", the price point (for what... your taste buds receive) is steep, and the service is hit or miss. I got a breakfast sandwich today with sausage, egg andcheese on a sesame bagel. It was bland and the sausage could/should have been heated up longer. I cannot say I'll be runningback to Gib's anytime soon. If you're looking for a true New York bagel in Colorado, do yourself a favor and visit Rosenberg'sBagels in Denver. While you're there, buy enough bagels to freeze at home. Read more
Gibbs is the best place to go for outstanding customer service, bagels, atmosphere and friendly staff. Josh always remembers who... I am and is just the greatest when it comes to fast and excellent service. He makes you feel welcome. I will never go anywhereelse. Go try it and tell Him Danni sent you! Thank you Josh!! Read more
This place is always ready to provide you with an experience. From getting your order wrong, to dirty looks and comments from... the cheerful college students employed here. GO TO ANOTHER BAGEL PLACE! Read more