Reviews for Gib’s New York Bagels in Fort Collins, CO

Bagels were hard and not good, but the ingredients were solid. Had the bacon, egg and cheese bagel and semi enjoyed it. Not the... best, but not the worst. Check out other places before coming here Read more

Ordered delivery from the one off Harmony many times. Unfortunately multiple times we have ordered extra bacon for $1.75 and it... never seems to get added to the order, even though we payed for it. Usually I just let it go but today was my girlfriendsbirthday and it started off with a bit of disappointment because of your negligence. * Delivered through NOSH* Read more

The food and prices were good, but it was SO LOUD. The acoustics were dreadful and the music was blasting high enough to where... we practically had to yell to hear each other. My fiancé (who never gets headaches) started getting a headache. Also, it wasfreezing because they left the door open on a very cold morning. Read more

Ever since noco nosh has become integrated with online orders bagel sandwiches keep getting more and more expensive, plus... automatically adding a tip for a pick up order is unusual too. Always enjoy the sandwich though, just too bad things havechanged Read more

This location is always quick and always has ample seating. Even if you come by an hour before closing there?s still a decent... selection! Read more

We had a super early breakfast catering order for 40+ people. Gib's had everything ready to go for us as soon as we arrived for... pickup. Everything was prepared exactly as ordered, hot, and tasty! Read more

As an immune compromised customer, I find it very unprofessional and dangerous to see multiple employees not wearing masks... during the current mask mandate. Not only were multiple employees not wearing masks properly, they allowed multiple customers toenter and order without masks. Pretty sad to see such a blatant disregard for public health and safety. I?ll definitely not bereturning to this location again. Read more

Pretty good. Love the option of all the bagels. I would have given it five stars if I knew the process of making the bagels and... what type of ingredients they put into it. Other than that, the cream cheeses they make are yummy and the bag was good too. Read more