Reviews for Eileen's Colossal Cookies in Fort Collins, CO

Really good! The cookies were all soft and sweet, and the frosting is fantastic and tastes flavorful but not overly sweet or... fake. All the cookies were great and the price is low too. Read more

This place is amazing!! I actually don?t even live in Colorado, so it was a trip up there. I ordered it online, and I asked if... they could put a yellow SUV that is similar In shape to Nissan X-terra. They went above and beyond to add the details; sosomeone really took the time to make my sons birthday cookie amazing!! He just loves it! They even wrote X-terra on the topwhere it is on a real car! Thank you so much to the workers who made this! (Cookie made it home in one piece, but sides got alittle smooshed from a near accident) Read more

Custom decorated ooey gooey cookies that will melt in your mouth. I like their personalized chocolate chip cookie so much I... brought it for a birthday party rather than a cake. The cookies are so irresistible it will be hard to walk out with only one! Read more

I ordered 17 dozen logo cookies for a 50th anniversary celebration. They turned out so lovely and tasted great as well. It was... really nice to have them individually wrapped. Will definitely order again. Read more

First time customer and really impressed! Came just as I asked and was delivered same day ordered. I will definitely use again... and recommend to others. Appreciate the impressive product you turned out in speedy time. Thank you! Natalie Woodward Read more

These guys are fantastic!!! My daughter is in college here (13 hours away from home) and they make it super easy to surprise... her with special occasion cookie cakes. They?re always beautiful and delicious and they make delivery a breeze. Thanks forhelping me show some love. ?? Read more

Highly recommend! They were helpful and quick for a last minute birthday cake!! And went above and beyond on the decorations!... Even was able to use UberEats on this speciality cake! Read more

Have gotten Eileen's cookies for my kids' birthdays for several years and they have always done an excellent job with our image... requests. And the quality of their product is excellent as well. Thank you! Read more