Reviews for Theo's 24 Prime Steak's Seafood and Wine Bar in Fond du Lac, WI

Let's start by saying that the steak and burger were amazing! What bothered me was no mashed potatoes offered that day, no... onions and mushrooms offered for on top of my steak. The decor needs a bit of help, it seems very forgotten. And the end of thebar being used as a desk with messy paperwork isn't a good look either. When we spend $140 for 3 meals with no mixed drinks ordessert I expect a bit more. We will only go back for burgers, probably to go. Read more

Can't even make good french fries, the food is way over priced so you don't get anything close to what you expect, bland food,... soggy fries and even the salad could have been better. Read more

Always great customer service from all the bar staff and servers. Filet mignon melts in ya mouth

Overpriced for the portion size. Two fish dinners 1) 3 piece 1) 5 piece. The billl was $44.15 no bar drinks. The final straw was... $3.00 credit/debt card $47.15 plus tip. I didn't expect to pay a fee to enjoy 2) overpriced fish dinners. Won't make thismistake again. Read more

Nicole left with my credit card for 10minutes, she didn't ask for an ID when I ordered alcohol. And she didnt tell us the... specials or ask us for drink orders. The 5 for $13 potstickers were ok Read more

The staff were very friendly. We ordered the shrimp cocktail for an appetizer, and the shrimp were ginormous! I ordered the... filet and it was perfectly cooked - just melted in my mouth. The mashed potatoes had a hint of horseradish and didn't tastefresh at - like they were reheated. Overall, good experience. I'd recommend. Read more

The atmosphere and the staff are wonderful. Especially when it is slower. I love coming in and am always pleasantly surprised... at the ever changing menu and how delicious everything is. Definitely a recommend. Read more

We enjoyed the tastes of the food and the dining experience. The crab cakes are outstanding as an appetizer. The steaks were... tasty but I've had steak's with better flavor and more tender than what we ordered. Soup or salad fresh bread and a side ofpotatoes and vegetables. I got two small red potatoes with my steak my wife. French fries with her steak. In the front entrancetheir feature was sea bass or porterhouse. I should have asked the price for the porterhouse before I ordered it because itwasn't worth $42. The homemade soup is creamed spinach and it had small diced potatoes. That soup was outstanding. Be aware thisis a very expensive restaurant we did not leave without paying the $150 bill for Just the Two of Us on a Wednesday night.Parking is adequate it is on street parking restrooms were clean barroom is well-stocked with Wine & Spirits in many differenttappers of beer. Friendly kitchen and wait staff. Read more