Reviews for Mattingly's Tavern in Florida, NY
Nice place to grab something to eat and drink ???? while watching sports. ????
What a great place! Bartender was exceptional. Food was very good. Set up was very good and the ability to easily gamble on... multiple platforms was a nice feature. The other patrons were friendly as well. I would absolutely recommend going there andshall return even though it is off my beaten pathway. Easy 5 star call on this establishment! Read more
We went here to watch some live local music. We had dinner first and the food was delicious. They did give me the wrong burger... by mistake but I am not a picky eater and I ate it anyway. It's was absolutely delicious. They have a good drink selection andgood environment. I would recommend it. Read more
Unclean tap lines. Oktoberfest beer was soured on tap and it?s October! Bar pie was like prison food. Cook dropped our pizza to... us and said ?that?s extra breading?. Whatever that means! Couldn?t even pull the ?slices? to separate. Broke a plastic knifetrying to get even a piece. It got spit out as soon as the first chew happened. Tasted rotten and hard as a rock! How are placeslike this still open. Read more
This place was fantastic! Their wings are phenomenal (I'm partial to their garlic parmesan and Jack Daniels Honey BBQ). They... have a wide assortment of beers on tap, including a hard cider. The atmosphere is aesthetically pleasing and the service iswonderful. Both of the Erin's are so pleasant, as well as knowledgeable/quick behind the bar. Will absolutely be returning Read more
Newly renovated the space is really lovely. The bartender, although very nice, is often distracted and it's hard to get her... attention. The beyond burger was delicious and the food in general was pretty good. It's a good local sports bar option. Read more
I liked this place the bartender was nice ???????? the owner was there but didn?t say a is everything ok , but ok the fries... where delicious the steak burger ok ,it doesn?t have taste , and the wings where good I ordered bbq tang it?s a bit spicy. Imostly liked the beers idk if I?ll ever return maybe next time try something else .??????????? Read more
Excellent food, we visited on a fundraising night for local softball. Was impressed with the dedication to the community.