Reviews for New Jersey Pizza Co in Flagstaff, AZ
I'm a pizza connoisseur and recently moved from Detroit to Flagstaff. 90% of the pizza I've had has been terrible until I found... this place. This will be my go-to place out here. The only thing to keep in mind is the wait for the pizza but it's well worthit for the quality you get instead of some thrown-together tasteless pizza I've had many times over while on my hunt. I'll betrying other menu items soon and will post about them as I go along but for now, they have me hooked on the pizza and Iappreciate their standards for quality and how friendly the staff is. Update: Tried their wings and cannoli, absolute amazing.Also tried a few other pizza spots but this one still stands as the best place. Read more
10/10! Everything about this pizza was great! The staff was super friendly and helpful, their dining room is being renovated but... they have some bar seating and recommended a nearby park to enjoy our pizza (it was perfect!) We loved the white and meat loverspizzas, I especially loved the fresh mozzarella/chevre combo that they include on a lot of their pizzas and the crust wasperfect. We ate cold leftovers for breakfast this morning, it was that good. A great stop especially when you?re not feeling upfor the logistics of finding a spot downtown. We will definitely be back on our next trip through flagstaff! Read more
Pizza was incredible! Crust and sauce were so good. Could tell it was made in house. Best I?ve had in a long time! They were... also very friendly. Read more
My first meal in AZ as an east coaster and I?m not disappointed! Kind owner, fresh ingredients on my vegan pizza, and great... crust! Will be back! Read more
The crust was good, but the pizza was very greasy. Overall taste was okay, and I'm sure would have been better with less... grease. The wait times we're over an hour, so I must be in the minority regarding the taste ????. The guys behind the counterwe're awesome, very friendly and funny. Read more
Best pizza in Flagstaff and it's not close. As someone from the phila/NY area, this is the only pizza that is true New York... style. It does take longer than little Ceasars or fratelli but the quality is worth the wait. The two guys running the shop arealso both extremely friendly and professional. As you can see by my picture I couldn't even wait to take a pic before eating aslice, yes it's that good. Read more
Wonderful Jersey/NY style pie right in town. Gentleman who answered the phone and assisted with pickup was very friendly.... Probably the owner very sincere and gracious. The pies exceeded expectations both in presentation and taste. I have traveled allover the country, finding delicious pizzas is hobby of mine. The quality and taste made me feel as if I was dining in GreenwichVillage area of NY where critics agree many of the best pies are created daily. No dine in currently due to Covid but this didnot dampen the experience. The locally sourced ingredients and experienced labor that go into these pies is evident with everybite. This establishment is first rate all the way worthy of your patronage expecially in these times. Don't think I'll beordering from any other pizzeria again in town anytime soon. I'll be ordering from New Jersey Pizza Co exclusively for theforeseeable future. Read more
Best pizza on the East Side! 100% my favorite! Great ingredients, homemade vegan cheese, amazing staff and super delicious! ??... highly recommend it and can?t wait for next time! Read more