Reviews for Tony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant in Fishersville, VA

We do order here there pizza is really good . And we like there food.but my last order I also ordered pizza that was great.but... I ordered a meatball sub it was so burnt up and hard.i had to trash it .couldn't eat it.was very disappointed ???? I don't havemoney to spend on something I can't eat . There only 5 min down the road from me .how did it get so hard? Read more

Their pizza is Not bad at all! The dough is thicker than I like but it has great flavor. Their service is super fast and... friendly. My kid had their pasta and meatballs and he said it yummy too :) Read more

Customer service was amazing. Food was still hot when we got home. We ordered a meat lovers pizza, bbq wings, a vegetarian... stromboli and a house salad. Everything taste amazing, i just wish the portion size of the salad was bigger but overall lovedeverything Read more

This restaurant has definitely gone downhill!! Kids spaghetti was about half a cup of noodles with about 2 tablespoons of sauce... no garlic bread! Got calamari it was way over done!! Was like eating rubber bands!! Got a hamburger with french fries thehamburger was under done and the bun was hard and not toasted stale hard!!! I ask for everything no mayonnaise and I got a sliceof tomato and some shredded lettuce!! I got an apple tart that came with ice cream and the ice cream was literally in the samesize container they put the ketchup in for the fries! Maybe a tablespoon!! In the trash it went!! We ended up going toWendy?s!! This place used to be good I don?t know what happened but they?re not now if you want good pizza and food at areasonable price where you get your moneys worth go to new Brother?s Pizza in Fishersville 10 times better!!! I will never orderfrom here again! Read more

First time coming here after meeting the owner, Tony. Tony is a very nice, friendly person that really cares about his... customers. It is nice to see that the restaurant is ran by the owner. House Salad was delicious and even more spectacular withthe parmesan cheese added on top! I did not know what to eat or what to order to begin with! Everything looks so amazing &tasty. I went with the Crispy Chicken Alfredo. Very mouthwatering grilled chicken, pasta and sauce. Customer service wastop-notch and the hostess was very friendly. I will definitely come back with the rest of the family when I am in theFishersville-Waynesboro area. Read more

Most pathetic large Supreme pizza with extra cheese in my life!! You should be ashamed charging $25.00! I could count the... toppings on both hands and the cheese wasn't even melted all of the way! If Brothers wasn't on vacation, I would have sent itback and ordered from there! The only reason it got One star is because negative stars is not an option! Horrible. Read more

It was fabulous food! Great, fast service and comfortable ambiance and seating. I would definitely recommend this place and I... will be returning again. Alfredo sauce is delicious! Read more

This is a cute and very friendly restaurant! We visited during COVID, but they had a dine in option at 50% capacity as well as... take out option. We decided to dine in. They were busy but it sounded like they had a lot of take out orders. The staff wassuper nice and pleasant to chat with. They were very good at making sure our drinks did not run dry. Shout out to our greatserver Alex. We got an appetizer of garlic bread. We also ordered a Stromboli and Manicotti. This place is very reasonablypriced. We got an appetizer and two entrees for 28 dollars! In short we loved it. Per the boyfriend he says their marinarasauce is one of the best he has had! Read more