Reviews for Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria in Farmingville, NY
Best Italian in town and surrounding towns. It's not just a pizza place, although the pizza is fantastic, but the other food... they make is delicious. Everything I've tried here has been perfect. It's a little food place with big restaurant quality andthe portions are large. They have great specials and deals. It's worth a try, you'll forget any other place around. They deliveras well Read more
Amazing!!!! i am picky when it comes down to my pizza places and i am now hooked... Great job and you just made a new customer... for life over here!!!! if you live in the area and looking for great italian food give them a try you won't be disappointed... Read more
Wow. They catered a family event to include last minute changes. Food was absolutely fantastic and the owners and employees... are awesome also Read more
Just moved to the area recently and this is the only place I?ve had to try, all the entrees were amazing (penne vodka chic parm... marsala francaise) and also got a pie ! It was perfect ???? also the clever name is what got me in the door ???? Read more
Haven't been here in years until my neighbor gave me some pizza and I asked where he got it from and to my surprise it was... Goomba. It was excellent, I took my grandson and had a couple of slices, delicious. Good service also. Read more
Best pizza I?ve tried in the area. We?ve been here four years and we finally got our pizza place. We had a bit of a snafu with... SLICE. The people at slice promised that they would take care of the refund but ultimately made Johnny?s work for it. I don?tthink that?s very fair. I really hate app ordering. I think that adding a middle man just makes more room for issues. But I alsounderstand why our local places sign on. It?s a new age. Anyway, Goomba Johnny?s assured us that their in house delivery is onpoint and I believe them. It?s a good hearted family owned place with really tasty food. Definitely worth a bite! Read more
I live right up the road from these guys, and have ordered food many times, but lately have been ordering there much less. The... reason being no consistency in their cooking. I've had burned sausage parm heroes, bland tasting chicken parm heroes (I used toorder them many times a week), but not anymore. The first time I ordered a Sicilian pizza from them it was cooked well andtasted great. The next 2 times I ordered it I basically got a pizza's with raw unrisen pizza dough. Now this is happening to myregular pizza orders... I just got home with a regular pizza which is also undercooked. You can see the layer of uncooked doughunder the cheese.. It's like holding a floppy piece of fabric instead of a slice of pizza. I don't complain about bad food fromplaces I eat, unless I am ready to never go there again. That is where I am. Good bye Goomba Johnny's. Read more
When my family is visiting from Florida this is there go to place for takeout. So I make a phone call and we always get the... Lobster Bisque Soup, Garlic Knots, and a variety of Pizzas. OMG, absolutely delicious! We love the owner Dominick and staff.Everyone is welcome and friendly. They have the best coupons. We highly recommend! Read more