Reviews for Harleys American Grille in Farmingdale, NY
I reccomend making a reservation this place is popular in farmingdale. The food was delicious the setting is very nice. The... service did take long however to get our check and stuff after eating. Read more
Hostess was a little shy with as may for my ethnic waiter is very friendly the east of the personal are very care even so they... had an event at that time the service was good looks like the people that frequent this place are happy with it the food is goodtaste right moisture meats was cook right for my taste a little bit over price for the quantity quality of the food was goodoverall ???? ???? ???? Read more
This place is a pretty nice overall , hit or miss on some of the dishes depending on what you like .. I think the short rib is... pretty solid and def love some of the starters including the spring rolls. The Brussels sprouts are always delicious. Drinks aresolid and fun... service is always very nice and attentive... good experience, every time I come here. Read more
We decided to go here for brunch and we had a great time. Omlets were excellent! And we shared the Nutella French toast. Yum!
The food wasn't horrible, but for the price we paid I expected a lot more. Service was abysmal and the place wasn't busy. Our... server disappeared for a half hour. We waited probably close to an hour to get our food. All in we spent about $250 for 2drinks, a porterhouse for 2 and some sides. $9 for a baked potato. The steak was okay, but at $120 it needs to be better thanokay. We ordered creamed spinach but I didn't try it. Overall the whole experience just felt like lipstick on a pig. The placelooked nice, there were lots of staff, but somehow service and food were lacking, despite demanding a premium price. Read more
The lamb chops were by far the worst lamb chops I've ever eaten in my life. Also they were completely raw in the middle.... Horrible taste. Got chicken fingers for my kid. Also the worst chicken fingers I've ever seen. 711 has better food. Best thing Iate was the carrots. So I guess order carrots. Read more
We came to Harley’s for our 1st anniversary after seeing rave reviews on all the review apps. We started off so well with a... super attentive hostess who congratulated us and joked with us. We were met with a great intro from the waiter however thatdidn’t last long. He would disappear for lengthy times. We never received any bread for the table. Our appetizers came outfairly quickly but the calamari was falling apart and not super crispy. The sweet chili wings were not just caramelized but dryand over cooked. We continued because we ordered everything at once. It took another about half hour to get our porterhouse fortwo and our four sides. We ordered the porterhouse medium rare, but it came nearly blue on some pieces and the outside wascharred a bit too much. It seemed as if they put the butter and thyme on the edge of the plate but it never touched the steak.The steak was very dry and crispy on the outside and too undercooked on the inside. There was a sprinkle of salt but that’sall for flavor. The steak was undercooked enough that the fat on the steak was not rendered completely and was inedible. Thecreamed spinach was very runny as if more like a soup. The baked potato we asked just for sour cream and butter but stillreceived the whole loaded toppings selection which was nice. The Brussels sprouts were the highlight and the best item weordered. Everything else was subpar for about $250 for two people. We likely wouldn’t come back and would not suggest it foranyone else. We arrived at 4 and the restaurant was empty, there should have been more to the meal. To add: our waiterdisappeared for lengthy times, the longest being a little over 20 minutes and we had to ask another server to get our check forus. It also took two rounds of about 10 minutes each to box up the leftovers. We were not offered dessert but likely would nothave stayed. We should have gone with our gut and gone elsewhere. It could have been an off day but it was a VERY off day. Bart Read more
Service was amazing, everything was very fresh, I had the Cesar salad and skirt steak, and gelato (Vanilla) highly recommended.