Reviews for Bay34th Street Pizzeria in Farmers Branch, TX

Wow, I stopped in because I saw the sign about the best NY slice in town. I thought what the heck. All I can say is I?m glad I... came in and I will be back! The slice was great. And their garlic knot with pepperoni was the best ever. Great food. Greatvalue. A winner for sure. Read more

My family and I dropped in for a late lunch after the beignet spot next door was unavailable. I?m glad we got to try Bay34th... Street! Their service is great and the Philly cheesesteak tasted amazing! The French bread is impressive and reminiscent of whatI?m used to in NOLA. We?ll certainly return for another visit. Read more

Good East coast feel. Food is good. Pizza by the slice on display. Always a good place to have as a go to place.

The calzones where incredible ????, the owners where very curtious and provided excellent service ?????. They lunch special is... less than 10 dollars and I could even finish all of my food????. Easily one of the best Pizzerias (not only in Dallas but all ofTexas) looking forward to dining here again ???? Read more

First off I asked for 8 pm delivery. I ordered the food at 6:20 pm. It was delivered at 6:45 pm. Had I not been at my hotel... it would have been a problem. The meatballs are nothing special at all. The sandwich was nice and toasty when delivered early:I wasn't hungry yet. Thats why I asked for 8 pm delivery. The spinach roll or what ever they call it was burnt to death,flavor was still there. They need to listen to request way better. Sauce was great, salad was great. Listen, listen, listen,I repeated my self 3 times stating when I wanted delivery. Stop, burning the tops of your rolls. Ratings on this place we're4.6 when I ordered. I would give this a 3.5 on food and a 3.5 overall. The worst part of all this is I had to warm up my foodin the hotel microwave, which made it kinda mushy, had they delivered it when asked I'm sure it would have tasted better, andbeen less mushy. Read more

So I was pleasantly surprised by this pizza. It was REALLY good. I ordered for lunch on a Friday and honestly expecting okay... pizza but it was great! Love supporting small business and I wish I lived in the area so I could order more often! I'lldefinitely be back though! Read more

Normally I love this place. We eat here all.the.time and we always order the same thing. We ordered and arrived and were paying... 13 minutes later. We ate in house after calling in the order. Tonight our pizza was doughy. I brought it to their attentionright after biting into it and peeling off the toppings to see. There is zero chance this thing sat in the warmer and that?s whyit appeared doughy, as I was told. They wouldn?t remake it. This is poor customer service for a regular customer no less. I?llbe keeping this in mind next time we consider eating here. Read more

LOVE LOVE LOVE their chicken wings!! Great spot for a quick, delicious lunch! They were recently awarded the 2020 Yelp Pizzeria... of the Year! Colleagues I have dined with say the pizza and calzones are delicious too! Plus, the owner and staff are superfriendly! We're glad you're in the Farmers Branch community! - Grace Speese, President Farmers Branch Chamber of Commerce Read more