Reviews for Jeremiah's Tavern in Fairport, NY

Great place to eat in Penfield. Fast service and great food. Generous portions on top of the salads. Highly recommend. I enjoyed... the Classic Caesar Chicken Salad but this time I went with the classic Caesar shrimp salad. Read more

Love Jeremiah?s! Food is always great and the service is friendly and fast. Today my bar server was Hallie, and she literally... brought our table beer in under 2 minutes. Thanks Hallie, keep up the great service!!we will see you again soon! Read more

Just average. It really is. The service is very questionable and the food just so so. They used to have good wings but now... they are tiny and not worth the cost. The fact is that their previous success went to their head(s). You can do better withyour hard earned money. You really can. Read more

Had a wonderful time yesterday with my sister and her grandchildren we had the fish fry and it was wonderful and Mac and Cheese... from the children?s menu for her granddaughter. Cole who our server was what made the experience a 5 he went above and beyondgood service. Not only would I recommend I plan going in the future! Thank you again Read more

Good drinks and good food... if you get the food you ordered. Two times now I've ordered food here for pickup and recieved... something wrong or different. Example May 25 2022 I ordered a black and blue burger, Now that comes with the Burger, bacon,Pepper jack cheese, and blue cheese, then i added mayonnaise onion and lettuce added...I got a burger with bacon and cheese on abun. So I would check your food before you leave. Read more

Excellent food and service. Will definitely go again!!

I stopped by for a burger today while a buddy mine and I were out running errands. First of all, I would like to acknowledge... Alicia, our server. She was awesome! Alicia is a consummate professional, very friendly, and extremely helpful. She is thereason I'm giving five stars, Thanks Alicia!I had a Burger and nachos, everything was delicious! Well done Jeremiah's Tavern! Read more

Delicious! Waitress was super kind and recommended favorites on the menu. My guests got the Bee-hive salad (said it was SUPERRR... hot but delicious) and nachos. I got the schnitzel sandwich, bread was so tender, sauce was delicious, macaroni salad was sogood! Hey quality food. There was a wait - surprisingly packed for a Monday! We did outdoor dining which was a nice option.Masks were few and far between to be seen here. Would definitely go back. Read more