Reviews for Nicholas Creamery in Fair Haven, NJ
HIGHWAY ROBBERY and CASH ONLY. Forces you to use an ATM with a steep withdrawal fee. NO EXCUSE for this nowadays. ANYONE can... accept credit cards. $10 for two ping pong balls worth of ice cream. Disgraceful. This place will fail. Read more
What a great find! I was in the area, looking for a dessert spot and found Nicholas Creamery. The young man behind the counter... was so very kind and welcoming! Greatest as I walked in too- first impression is everything.. the ice cream is very rich, creamyand enjoyable. Will definitely be back next time I?m in the area. Read more
Nice little ice cream shop. Good flavors. Scoop are small but for the price, I think it works out. $5.25 for two scoops. The... young lady seemed to be annoyed since we were asking questions since it was our first time here. Read more
The ice cream from here is fantastic. I love the seasonal ice cream and out of the box flavors. I am giving you only three stars... because your employees are very uncomfortable. I was faced with uncertainty and judgment. I was treated like a spectacle. If youare willing to go to an ice cream place where their employees judge you for getting ice cream from a job they work at then thisplace is for you. Read more
It?s safe to say that Nicholas Creamery sells the best ice cream in Monmouth County. The flavors are always fresh, the service... is always efficient, and the owners are outstanding. I also went to school with Mr. Harary?s son and can say that they?re anamazing family. Super kind, skilled, and welcoming Read more
Great little spot for delicious, small batch, artisan ice cream. Original flavors like Fluffernutter (peanut butter and... marshmallow, of course), Brown Sugar Cookie Dough, Mango Coconut and more ?adult? flavors like Cherry Goat Cheese and TahitianVanilla. There were so many tempting flavors, we considered a ?flight? of 6 scoops but begrudgingly talked ourselves out of it.We maintained self control and vowed to be back soon to try another flavor or two. Read more
Making the rounds to all 3 locations, this time Fair Haven. Tried the GOAT and Booskerdoo coffee flavors and loved them. This... ice cream is special. Read more
Overrated! I was very disappointed because I only came due to the great reviews. We tried peaches and cream, watermelon, and... vanilla. The Ice-cream are not creamy, don't feel fresh and barely have any taste. Honestly one of the worse ice-cream I've everhad. Two stars because the staff was Amazing and welcoming. Read more