Reviews for Gardo's Italian Oven in Evansville, IN

I've noticed this place while eating at the Darmstadt Inn for many years, but never got around to trying it. Finally got a strom... there, and it is top-3 for sure. Excellent! Read more

Best stromboli in the tristate. Great family owned business. They will bring your order out to your vehicle. This place has some... of the best pizza and bread sticks as well. The staff are super busy but will always take time to thank you for the business. Itis a great way to get a nice warm meal and support local establishments. Read more

Not happy that I can't get thru on the phones hardly ever especially for lunch they never pickup phone I've been only been able... to order one time because the phones are always down Read more

Pizza was served nice and hot although I didn't care for the crust too thick and chewy

Some of the best pizza on the northside of Evansville. The pizzas, their sides, and salads are all great. Highly recommend.

Best Stromboli sandwich I've ever had!! So glad I made the jaunt away from the highway for something other than fast food. It's... mainly carryout but they were kind enough to let me dine in and take a break as I drove cross country. Super friendly! Woulddefinitely stop again. Read more

Update (3/13/22) - updated review is pending, today we called and they are delivering to our location. Great Pizza! 4 Stars -... only because delivery is sketchy, apparently we live just outside their 5 mile radius and it's up to the discretion of whomeveris delivering that day if they will deliver to us. [Original review - I was ready to give Gardo's 5 stars - great pizza, betterthan the others we've had for delivery. But alas, they changed their mind and refuse to deliver to us now one month aftergetting our 1st pizza delivered from them. A 10 minute drive, shorter than Twisted Tomato that WILL deliver to us!] Read more

A sign by door said not to come in and to order from the car. So we got the number and called them to order a sandwich from the... parking lot (while watching people come in and out of the shop). The sandwich was said to take 30 minutes... for a sandwich...and it is not like they were very busy, so that's ridiculous. It was Sunday, so we expected to have the special $1 off like itsaid on the website but nope. They said they couldn't do that because of covid, like that's a real reason not to do specials.The food was a 3 star, the service was a 2 star, but how they run a business is a 1 star. Read more