Reviews for Casey's in Evansville, IN
Fantastic pizza from a gas station! Checkout the app for pizza deals that will save you money. Chicken bacon ranch pizza is... very good as well. Read more
Love the pizza but being told that it will be ready by a certain time and you go to pick it up and its just being made. Sounds... like you need to hire faster people for the kitchen. Read more
I've worked at the Santa Claus Casey's for over a year, and I've gotta say: this is the WORST Casey's I have ever eaten at. The... pizza I got was super greasy and soggy, I could barely eat it. They use the same equipment they've been using since the storeopened for business, and the store itself looks ANCIENT. It tells you a lot about the management and the corporate managementwho work for that store, how they feel about working there. I absolutely do not recommend eating any food made there. Read more
Love their pizza and they have free AIR, how many places have that anymore.... far and few between.
Flippen love Caseys no matter where Iam. Their pizza n cookies are amazing!!!! Customer Service always helpful an hospitable.... The Princeton Caseys has a cashier I believe shes still there idk. Her name is Oliva Pena most definitely one of the sweetestcashiers I have come acroos. Read more
This is the convenience store closest to my house and it's also the best one in Evansville as far as I can tell. They have a... wide variety of food, the fountain drinks taste better than anywhere else, and the people are always very friendly. Read more
Casey's pizza is a guilty pleasure of mine. I went in for a slice and they were out of cheese . I looked at the guy behind the... counter and asked if they would make any cheese and he said "nope, my bad" while he ate his piece of pizza. he wasn't even onbreak! one star Read more
Great store,pple are so friend,and it has clean bathrooms