Reviews for Paul's Live From New York Pizza in Eureka, CA
You'll know from the delicious smell that this place is good. Far better than your average pizza by the slice. We liked the... Sunset, a vegetarian Hawaiian pizza. Read more
Not going to lie one bit they have ruined a pizza for me and my family with how good the options were. I bought food for five... people total of about what I think I bought seven slices for less than 50 bucks and they were all very good. I cannot competewith that anywhere near where I'm at so I feel really bad now. Read more
Honestly the best pizza I've had in town BUT the lady working the register was the worst experience I've ever had with... restaurant staff. We had to say our order five times but she kept interrupting and trying to do a whole standup comedy routine. She was not funny and was terrible at her job to the point where we are only going to the Arcata location from now on so wenever have to interact with her again. Read more
I had the Hot stuff Pizza and garlic knots and my daughter had the cheese pizza, she was absolutely raving the whole time saying... it was the best pizza she's ever had. The food was amazing and the staff were very friendly, the space was very clean and theyhad bomb ranch. What more can you ask for ????. Read more
Pizza by the slice in Eureka! It's a no frills pizza joint. The pizza itself was really good. The pesto on it was great.... Cashier was very pleasant. Read more
The ordering was confusing. No one to help and girl counting out other register made no attempt to make eye contact and explain... the situation. After about 5 minutes some one came out and took our order. I was very frustrated. But the pizza was excellent. Read more
We?re not from the area and we asked one of our friends that is, where the best pizza was in Eureka and he told us to check out... Paul?s Live from New York!! Very open setting made for larger groups! You can order whole or by the slice pizzas! The have aspecial everyday that looks very appealing to the eye! The taste and the crunch was perfect!! I will be coming back when I visitagain!! ???? Read more
BEWARE: HOURS ARE VERY FLEXIBLE!!! So after living here quite a while we decided to on a whim give them a try since we were just... down the street and stressed enough for our day to not have to cook something. We walk up over two and half hours prior to theposted close time, and walk in just to be told they were closing. There were several parties still eating inside, so not acomplete ghost town. We were giving to options of a very slim selection of who knows how old of pizza. I was hoping for the fullexperience given it was out first time. But no, shooed out two and hours and 36 minutes prior to closing, with an open signstill glowing in the window. Are posted hours just not a thing anymore, whether online or on the brick and mortar building!?! Ifrestaurants wonder why people aren?t coming out after COVID, some consistency would help! Either change your hours or own up tothem (if you change them, make it known)!!! I?m all about supporting local, small businesses 1000% more than most people, but Ihave no problem not if you?re going to run things like a spastic child and can?t be relied upon. Get it together! Read more