Reviews for Tavern on the Hill in Enola, PA
08/18/2022: New server Alexa was awesome. Never wouldbhave known she was only on her second week. Food was, as usual,... exceptional. Only place Ive ever dined at that had Metallica on piano..lol. will be back again soon! 2022 Update: Have eatentwice since the first review. Both times the meal was near perfection. Definitely has become our go to place for fine dining. Michael was a hilarious plus. He was our server and took good care of us. All around a great place to get good food. Googlewas nice enough to recommend or we never would have heard of the place. So the service was fantastic, and the food was verygood. We had oysters Rockefeller and escargot for appetizers. Both prepared nicely and served hot. Salad was good. Had scallopsand wife had lobster. Both were good, but not quite up to the quality standards I would have expected compared to theappetizers. Lobster was slightly over cooked, as was the scallops. But.. just very slightly, and I am being picky. Overall,nice place and we will definitely come back. Read more
Amazing food, amazing service, clean and beautiful. All the food was delicious but the baked potato OMG! Best I have ever had. ... Everyone was so kind and nice. Read more
Outstanding meal this evening of Australian Barramundi covered with crab claws and seasonal vegetable, Crab Imperial, Oysters... Rockefeller, French Onion Soup, Salads with a Tavern on the Hill dressing, Combination grilled vegetables, Asparagus, SauvignonBlanc, Margarita, Peanut Butter Tort. All the staff greeted us pleasantly and were attentive. I shall return very soon! Read more
Used to love the place. The service is still great but food … The most recent meal we had there was not fresh to say the... least . Crab claws had strong aftertaste… shrimps were mushy . Seabass was simply tasteless and poorly prepared. Unclearwhat caused it exactly, we think perhaps crab claws , but 3 out of 7 of us had diarrhea during the night - early morning afterthe dinner . We were there on Saturday night at 6:30 and some of the items on menu were not available already .. once again , I use to love this place … Read more
Celebrating an anniversary and gad the chance to eat here for the first time. Good atmosphere and service was great. ... Appetizers were very good and dinner was brought out quickly and had a great presentation. Read more
Food was delicious. We will return. We were disappointed because we specifically wanted the crab cakes but they were not on... the menu the night we were there. Read more
My favorite local restaurant. Never ceases to amaze! Menu is superb as is the presentation, wine list, and hosts. Plus their new... outdoor enclosed patio makes you feel like you are Italy. I love this place! Elegant, eclectic and old world charm. Read more
Worst experience ever. I made reservations for a special occasion. It was special alright! Horribly special. 1.) seated with no... menu as the waiter goes to take a order and realized this.. 2.) waiter was the pits 3.) ordered coffee. Waiter forgot it. 3.) 10minutes later the waiter brings a cup of cold coffee 4.) we advised the waiter that the coffee was cold. Training waitressBrings another cup steaming hot but it tasted old like it’s been sitting all day, Horrible. 5.) it’s freezing cold in there.So cold another waiter says “ it is Artic cold right here.” No one asks if we are alright/ if we wanted the air turned down,Nothing. After 35 minutes of waiting we finally get our appetizer and salad, with 2 pieces of sliced bread and frozen butter ( in plastic ) 6.) we waited 40 minutes in the freezing cold for the waiter to come and check on us. Only to advise us that thefood will be a little while longer. As we advised him that we were contemplating leaving. So we wait. 7.) another 15/20 minuteswaiter comes back and says “ I’m sorry but we are backed up.” We are still freezing.We get the manager (I assume) andadvise her that we are uncomfortably cold. She turns the air down, but by this time I am frost bitten and still haven’t gottenmy food. I got up and advised the manager that we are leaving. She says “your food just came out.” We advised her that wedon’t want it and to keep it. We paid for it and left. This was my first time here. I heard this was a really good place. Ihave never experienced horrific service like this. I have gotten better service at McDonald’s. So is this what we call finedining? I spent $135.00 for the worst Dining experience ever. Lesson; If the coffee is bad then the service and food probablyis too. Read more