Reviews for Brooklyn Square Pizza in Manalapan Township, NJ
I was a customer when it was Peter pan in Brooklyn. Large pie with sesame seeds on the crust. My brother from jersey thought it... was the best he ever had. I was with him yesterday and we decided to see if it's as good as it was in Brooklyn. It's not. It wassmall, unevenly cut. A hint here and there of sesame seeds. The dough is dense and tough with a lot of crust. It was floppy.Place is super busy on a Friday and it was an hour wait for a pie. It definitely didn't own up to its Brooklyn roots. We weredisappointed Read more
Once upon a time, a good pizza. Unfortunately, now it is always sloppily made and undercooked. After a particularly bad... experience, I reached out to the owners. They replied back indicating they were sorry and would credit me - but ghosted me afterthat. Read more
Just tasted the much talked about upside down. Not bad but I've tasted better pizza. Can't say I'll make a half hour trip again... to pay $26, when I can get better tasting pizza in my area for less. Much to do about nothing. Read more
Excellent place. Seems unfairly under advertised, or perhaps I've never heard of it, but that's now changed. Service was... excellent. Very polite, friendly, attentive. Food was delicious. Authentic pizza, great pasta and awesome salad. Definitely hitthe spot, so much so we're still talking about it the next day. Read more
I started following a FB group for pizzas and came across this spot. I know ppl rave a lot of this style of pizza so decided to... give it a try. It?s definitely heavy but hey its pizza, u r supposed to feel like a fat a$$ after you eat. ???? Ordered the pieand picked it up in 29min. The sauce was flavorful, hint of sweetness cuts through the tanginess of the tomatoes. I loaded up myslice with an overload of chili flakes and voila, I was in a zone that I can?t really express. I had the middle piece firstfollowed by the end piece. Totally bliss !!! The only thing I would change for next time is to have them cook a lil more, tomake it crispy. I popped my slices on a pan and they were perfect. Will def eat here again. If you haven?t checked this placeout, stop by today and pickup a pie. Read more
1st time ordering the upside down pizza and it was just okay. 2nd time I ordered, I tried jersey Square and it taste so much... better even though it seemed like the same pizza except for pepperoni being on it. It also tasted like it had some sweet spotsas if the sauce had sugar in it but only on certain parts. This is a pizza that I would eat when I'm in the area but not travelfor it. Read more
Pizza ready when they said it would be. Love the crust on their round pies. I normally do not ask for sesame on the crust but... this place makes it so good that I specifically come here for their crust and the delicious pizza. Finally tried the upside downpie after exclusively ordering the plain round and white all the time. It was very good and the tasty sauce was the standout.Not the best i had, but very good and especially for the area. White pie above average as well. I have not had better yet withina 5-10 min drive of this place so I do recommend it if you are in the area. Read more
I'm not always into Sicilian style pies but Brooklyn Square knocks it out of the park. There is a subtle sweetness that is... clearly unique. This pie was even better the next morning. Read more