Reviews for Original Italian Pizza in Elmira, NY
Great antipasto salad! Really like the pickled veggies they use. Thw salad came in a big serving, wnough for multiple people to... enjoy. Good service too, brought us the food when it came out. Read more
Great cheesesteaks as well as Stromboli. They also have garlic salt which is authentic and goes well with their Italian food.
I'm so very disappointed! My spaghetti was so watery hardly any sauce. I should take a picture of the water in the spaghetti. !... And it's COLD! MY Husband's pizza was not done. I understand they were going to close soon after we placed the order and Idid call to *complain". But I couldn't eat the spaghetti. Thankfully I had a salad. And the bread was hard and cold. I'mextremely disappointed ??..I couldn't figure out to show how much water was in the spaghetti.. I'm extremely disappointed forpaying 30. Plus dollars for horrible food. And when I asked her for extra sauce, she was happy to say she put a lot of sauce!! SERIOUSLY!! I CAN'T FIGURE OUT HOW TO POST THE PICTURE! I WANTED SPAGHETTI NOT SOUP!? I posted a picture..I didn't eat any ofit..the picture is just showing how watery it is! Read more
My daughter recommended the Grilled Chicken Salad. For my first time eaten at OIP it was by far the best salad I've had in this... area. I strongly recommend this salad & can not wait to explore more options as well. Thank you for the speedy delivery &amazing food. Lorraine Zepp Read more
Refused to take my order because they closed soon. Never had another restaurant use the excuse that the owner doesn't want to... pay overtime so we can't make your food. Read more
Both times I've ordered they have messed my sandwiches up and had to resend another back to the house. The second time I also... ordered chicken parm w three meatballs and extra cheese. They forgot my bread and didn't put the extra cheese that in sure I gotcharged for.. but whatever I won't order again. The chicken seemed undercooked but some how still dry and tough.. two stars forthem correcting the sandwiches but need to stick to just cooking my own food Read more
Ordered medium chicken wing pizza and a order of cauliflower. The cauliflower was soaked in grease and soggy. The pizza... had... 8 maybe 10 chunks of what looks like boneless wings thrown on with barely any cheese. 3 inches of barely cooked crust. This wasa last resort as Vinny's is closed. Should have known better. The quality here has really gone down. Read more
We stop here every play/musical we see at the Clemons Center!