Reviews for Elkton Goodfellas in Elkton, VA
A great pizza place. So cheesy! We ate a veggie stromboli and a calzone. Big portions. It is like vintage and everything is... clean and neat. Our server was very friendly. Read more
This is the first time I have ever eaten at this restaurant but I say it has very good delicious food and a very good customer... service and affordable prices that I would highly suggest going to it if I were you and I do plan on going to this restaurantthe next time I'm in the town of Elkton Virginia. Read more
I have never had a bad meal here. Reasonable prices and food is always hot and tasty. I really enjoy their steak and cheese and... their pizzas. Read more
Great food and incredibly friendly staff. Portion sizes make the prices extremely fair if not a bit abundantly affordable. Only... negative aspect was that it seems to be slightly small, which normally wouldn't at all be an issue, but it's so small that therecan easily be someone way too loud making it difficult for anybody else to hold a conversation. Read more
Love this little place! We were on our way back from Luray and saw Goodfellas. We had to stop and check it out. The food was... great, priced well and fast. Our waitress made us feel like home and we will definitely be back when we pass through. Read more
Decent place to get pizza, subs, sandwiches, or pasta without breaking the bank. Inside is not fancy, service was hometown... friendly and quick. Expect 20 - 30 minutes wait during lunch hours. The owner has closed two out of six tables in therestaurant to keep dine in customers at a safe distance. Fork and knife are individually stored in a disposable bag. We haveordered three slices of pizza, meatballs parmigiana, and steak & cheese special. Pizzas were very good, definitely worth offive stars, however both subs were nothing special. I have mix feelings about this place, you will have to try and be thejudge. Read more
With a small diner feel, the food was tasty yet somewhat generic Italian fare. The steak and cheese special was decent, the... spaghetti was okay... but the calzones are worth mentioning. The large calzone was huge... and this is coming from a Texan,where everything is bigger back home. Good flavors and humongous portion, could have fed the whole table. All in all, nice homeylittle place with decent eats. Read more
Great place to eat with an equally great staff. Good selection at fair prices. Definitely will be coming back again.