Reviews for Tony's Pizza New York Style in St. Augustine, FL
Excellent!!! Supreme loaded with toppings!!! Wish I took a picture! 14" perfect for 2-3 ppl. Delivered to Point Matanzas in 35... min. Fair prices! Highly recommend! Read more
We were on vacation in butler beach we had ordered large pepperoni/cheeses?..WOW was impressed great ny style pizza cooked... perfectly!! We loved it! the driver was very friendly I would recommend for sure !!! Read more
I ordered an extra large two topping pizza for pickup. They told me 25 minutes. I got there in 25 minutes and it was ready and... I was out the door. Awesome tasting pizza, friendly staff and good prices. 5 stars. And everyone quit making statements youcannot prove like they never do this or always do that. Sometimes businesses get backed up. Read more
The cost is way too high for the quality of product, the store hours don't line up with their website, the pizza was heavily... salted and didn't have enough cheese. I added a small cheese pizza to our order and they seemed really annoyed by that fact. Notworth it. Read more
We had 2 of their calzones (the vegetarian and the steak and cheese). The calzones were HUGE, we had dinner that night plus... lunch and dinner the next day! By my second bite I knew I would fight any New Yorker who tried to say theirs was better. Bestpizza in my life, an absolute must-stop (even if you have to detour a bit)! Read more
EDIT: They don't accept dine in right now. It's only pick up or delivery but not really a problem. Still Great pizza and no... complaints. ORIGINAL REVIEW: Great pizza. It's a tradition for the family to get pizza here every summer. Very friendlystaff. Love this local pizza joint. Read more
The BEST of the best!!!! I never tasted such amazing homemade sauce like the one they make. The crust was incredible with the... darlic butter spread on top of it. The cheese was was just the right amount and had a generous amount of toppings. They arecrazy busy all the time but the wait was so worth it. Read more
Excellent pizza salads were fresh and crisp very pleasant worker will definitely be back