Reviews for Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard in St. Augustine, FL

Super long line in the summer heat but wonderful custard and milkshakes!! I got the Oreo shake and would definitely get again.

This place was amazing. Every time I go I try different flavors. All are different but very good. You need a treat on a hot day... or have a sweet tooth. This is the place for you. Read more

My Blue Raspberry frozen drink had chunks of peanut butter in it. Thankfully i have no food allergies but that could put someone... into anaphylactic shock; plus it?s just gross to not clean the machines well. Read more

My family of 4 (2 adults, a 10 yo, and a 6 yo) had dessert here on 4/7 during our Spring Break vacation in the Saint Augustine... area. My wife and I really miss Rita?s! We had them near our home years ago, but they all, sadly, shut down. As such, thiswas a real treat! The staff was great at taking orders and getting them out fast, and everything tasted as great as weremembered it! The kids loved it too! Read more

The absolute best ice cream. Not a "fast food" but worth definitely worth the wait time.

Amazing ice cream shop near St Augustine Beach. Ordered the blendini with Twist custard blended with Unicorn ice topped with... m&ms. It was really tasty and great size. Are the blendini while walking around the pier. Overall, awesome ice cream shop. Read more

Taste is good but spent $6 for concrete that is 60% full? Dairy queen it is even up into the rounded top......Nothing like the... picture on the window....... you can see in the pict with the top it does not even reach the red line......ridiculous. Read more

ordered the large sundae which came with a cherry, whipped cream and two choices of toppings. the frozen custard was delicious,... smooth, not too fat, but still very tasty. they were very generous with the toppings (almost too generous). we ate all three onone sundae, so the size of portion was more than adequate for the price. I'm not giving 5 stars because the service was somewhatslow and not too friendly and I was expecting a little bit more choices of frozen custard. but still a great place close to thebeach and good quality product. Read more