Reviews for Mayday Ice Cream Historic St. Augustine in St. Augustine, FL

Staff was very kind and pleasant when offering samples and explaining the flavors. There are quite a few unique flavors and a... couple tried and true. They offered complimentary home made sprinkles and waffle crisps which were delicious. Although theflavors were interesting the taste didn?t really come through well and the combinations didn?t work well despite sounding goodin the description. The ice cream also wasn?t very creamy. It was fun trying a new place and supporting local and my kids likedtheir sorbet. Read more

We love Mayday ice cream and love to stop at their stores. That's why we were so happy to find their outlet in the Old Town at... the corner of St.George and Hypolita St. The manager, Claire B (aka "E.Claire"), was utterly delightful and filled us in on thehistory of the Mayday brand. while dishing out some unbelievable flavors with a friendly smile. Mayday ice cream served up byE.Claire - a truly unforgettable combination. Read more

Smelled horrendous to me when we walked in on 07/21/22 @ 9:30pm. Staff were extremely kind, but seemed a bit out of sorts at... times and chatted to much with their friends in line. There were 3 dairy-free (?vegan?) options: pistachio and almond butterchocolate and then a 21+ fruity flavor. Ordered the almond butter chocolate ice cream. Wasn?t too sweet, which was good.However, it missed the mark. Flavor was watery to me and the almond wasn?t pleasant to my taste buds. The pricing is so weirdfor the ice cream scoops?.. $5+ for ?one scoop?. $7.25 for ?2 scoops?. $9.25 for ?6 mini-sized scoops? which the cashier told mewas actually LESS ice cream than the 2-scoop option!! If that?s true, then they are ripping you OFF! If it?s not, educate youremployees on up to date company policies better because they are warding off customers with inaccurate information. I?drecommend the one scoop for 1-person. 2 of us couldn?t finish the 2-scoop option. Read more

Great icecream???????? Tip: one flavor consists of three scoops so sizes are really large

We went to May Day twice during our weekend trip to St. Augustine. Got a flight to share each time so we could try a little of... everything. Our favorites were - Parent Trap, Tiki Trio and the lavender one was really good too. Read more

Delicious! We got a late night hankering for something sweet and came across this place. Stopped in about 25 minutes before... close and the staff was so welcoming. They told us to try as many flavors as we'd like and enjoy! My mum and I got a boozywatermelon flavor ???? (so refreshing!) and my uncle got salted caramel and banana pudding. ???? All were fantastic! Read more

Portions are enormous. You really get what you pay for. You can easily split even one scoop with two people. Flavors were... great. Had the strawberry and Nutella something.. it was delicious. Line is pretty long but it goes through fairly fast on theweekend. Def will be back! Read more

Really nice staff. Great flavors. Can?t go wrong. I had rocky road. My father in law tried the Chai Tea and I already forgot... what my husband got but they were all delicious. So glad we popped in. Read more