Reviews for El Potro Mexican Restaurant in St. Augustine, FL

Great tasting food for a decent price. Servers could be more attentive. Loud and hard to enjoy your meal with the volume.

Always consistent! Good stays hot 50+ min ride. Delicious sauce made in house can?t beat the prices either! Good stuff!!!

Wow! What a wonderful local gem. This place checked all the boxes for me. We had a sweet girl named Ryley greet us when we... walked in the door, she took care of us the entire time. We had the El Potro fajita and split it. Literally the BEST fajita I?veever had. This was filled with seasoned steak, chicken, shrimp, chorizo, and lots of veggies! Huge bang for your buck. We alsohad the guacamole dip as an appetizer and it was great too. We visit St. Augustine frequently and will definitely come back fora visit. If you?re looking for GOOD Mexican food with quick and friendly service look no further. Read more

Staff are excellent here! The server Jessica was really friendly and informative. The food is not authentic Mexican, I think the... recipes changed a lot since being handed down from the family that first made them. Overall, it was a good experience but thefood was really disappointing. Read more

Tony and I had dinner at El Potro Mexican Restaurant in St Augustine Florida. We have been eating seafood all week and since we... are in a town with Spanish Influence, we wanted Tacos...I was going to another restaurant but this one was much closer to VilanoBeach, so this was a better choice. Waiter was very helpful. He did a wonderful job and our food was so good!! Definitely wouldeat here again and highly recommend to anyone in the area. I had Grilled Fish and Grilled Chicken with beans and rice on theside. Great choice!! With an Iced Tea with lemon and lime. Tony had Steak and Chicken Tacos with Beans and Rice!! Of course aDraft Beer!!! Read more

This little Mexican place was Awesome!! The server was very nice and attentive to his customers. I felt very comfortable being... the first time coming to St.Agustine. Great price 100% authentic Mexican food. When ever I get a chance to come back this willbe my first stop.Thank you Tony L. For your great service. Read more

Our favorite Mexican restaurant in town! Good service and food. Reasonable prices.

The food was ok. Nothing to go crazy for but the service was awesome! I wish I would've asked the waitress her name to give her... the credit she deserves. There were about 5 tables and she took care of all of us by herself. She got every single last thingright and she didn't forget anything we asked for like in many other places. So even though I wasn't crazy about the food theservice alone is enough for me to stop by again when I'm in the area. Read more