Reviews for BARNACLE BILLS SEAFOOD HOUSE in St. Augustine, FL

Dont be fooled. This is not the same old Barnacle Bill's. No food available yet. Just a hotel bar. So disappointed the original... was sold with the name, but not the same great place! Read more

Great place to eat. Located in the Holiday Inn. Awesome taste and wonderful service.

Small seafood restaurant located at the Holiday Inn hotel, great food, great staff, affordable prices, during one of the busiest... days of the year the waiting line was not that bad considering that there were no reservations needed. I certainly recommendthis place from breakfast to dinning. Read more

This was our first time coming to the newer location. At the old location we received great service and amazing home made food.... We hoped to have the same at the newer location, but sadly no!!! The waitress we had was nice, but all the other people who"helped" her wasn't so great. Only two other groups there, definitely not busy. The food was horrible!!! We could have spentless at Winn Dixie for better food!!! What was supposed to be spicy was NOT at all. To top it off as we got ready to leave wecould hear the staff complaining about us bringing our kids. Seriously disappointed with the entire visit!!! Will NEVER comeback!!! Will NEVER recommend again!!! Read more

My burger came to me almost an hour after I ordered it almost entirely raw with the buns soaked in red blood. It was literally... purple-red colored except for the seared outside. After I showed the waiter and it went back to the kitchen for another 15minutes it came back to me slightly more cooked, but still raw in the middle, served on the same blood-soaked bun from before.They didn?t even remake it. The bread and vegetables were covered in blood. I was also given back cold fries. Awful diningexperience. The picture is AFTER it went back to the kitchen and came back to me still raw. I ordered medium-well for referenceand we were one of two tables in the entire restaurant. They weren?t even busy. Read more

Went on Father?s day with my family and was disappointed. We went in at a little after noon and was seated shortly. The... restaurant was pretty clean, your right next to the Holiday Inn lobby. My family ordered catfish and shrimp with various sides.I ordered the Florida Sunshine Salad (Pictured/ half eaten). It took about 30 minutes for us to get our food. There didn?t seemto be too many workers so it took forever despite there not being too many patrons. The food was good, though the fried shrimpwere somewhat salty. The salad was $12, + $6 with shrimp. My salad ended up coming with 5 small grilled shrimp. 5 shrimp for $6.Damn. There were also flies buzzing around, which distracted me from eating my $18 salad. Didn?t really enjoy this restaurant.You?re better off finding somewhere in the city to eat, the only positive is that you?ll have somewhere to park here. Honestlythat?s a pretty big plus when it comes to this city. Edit: Drink machine was broke too. Happy Father?s Day everyone! Read more

We heard for 3 days how great restaurant was in our hotel....raining, thunder and lightening decided we would try. From the... waiter that treated us like an inconvenience to the food over priced , over cooked, flavorless food. If you look closely at thegrilled fish, bread crumbs were an after thought thrown on fish, I had to scrape the mush off to eat.....we had such great foodin St. Augustine this was the most expensive meal and clearly not worth it! Read more

Menus were dirty, the teriyaki glazed shrimp over rice was ok but could have had a little more glazing sauce as the small amount... of rice was dry. Service was very good. Hush puppies were good. Overall I'd eat there again. Read more