Loading

Reviews for Amici Italian Restaurant in St Augustine Beach, FL

Ebony Marks 2 years ago
4

Only reason this is a 4 and not a 5 is because we had an hour wait for our food. Everyone is short staffed though, so we... weren’t upset. Just hungry and ready to head home. But our server was a gem, and the food was AMAZING. We were also able tosqueeze in a reservation last minute. So grateful for that! If we’re back in the area, we’ll return for sure. Great datenight OR family spot. Read more

L J Artica (LaLa) 2 years ago
5

Very ample portions of great authentic Italian food. We took half of it back to the room and had it for brunch the next day.... The service was excellent as well. Savory and delicious. Read more

Jordan & Rachel Jeeping Life 2 years ago
4

It was good Italian. We were able to make a reservation for 8 tonight a few hours before arriving to eat. The roasted garlic and... oil for the bread is very good. The fried mozzarella was very good. The eggplant Parmesan was in the top of the best I have Isay within the top 5. The chicken Cesar was very good and fresh. The tour of Italy was 10 times better than Olive Garden. Thehomemade Alfredo was good and you can definitely it was homemade. The waitress was nice and friendly but slacked on refillsmaybe they were short staffed. Read more

Wes Brown 2 years ago
2

Not happy with this at all. The portions were a joke. 26$ dollars for the Italian trio and 3 dollar up charge for chicken parm..... I got half of a chicken breast pounded flat, see picture... 3 meals 100$... as to your lying reply... yes you offered to 3$back...not taking into account the eggplant parm that was not on the plate. My party were my two kids who had their noses intheir phones, there was no disruption, we were quiet the whole time until I made my complaint at the end of the meal. We treatedyour server with respect the whole time. Read more

Xero 2 years ago
2

This is possibly the work pasta I have had in a long time. I ordered fettuccine with pesto sauce, shrimp and scallops. It came... with a Cesar salad and it was watered down. The shrimp and scallops were cooked very well; however the pesto sauce is the mostdisappointing thing I have ever tasted. It was mostly olive and it was extremely bland. Not to mention the charge $18 for 5scallops. Olive Garden has a better pesto and that’s not saying much. For the price it is definitely not worth it for 3 creatyour own pasta’s and one $9 alcoholic beverage the bill was over $100. I am holding my anger back in this review a lot. Idon’t recommend going here I I will not be supporting this establishment ever again. Read more

Chris Ottum 2 years ago
5

Wow...our server was friendly and knowledgeable, the food was DELICIOUS, and plentiful. I definitely recommend visiting, I'll be... going back the next time I'm in town. I can't recommend any one thing, because it was all so tasty! Read more

Rob Hernandez 2 years ago
4

Last minute stop with my wife as I was craving pasta and we happened to drive by. We both went with the "build your own pasta."... I had cheese tortellini in meat sauce and meatballs. Honestly, the chunks of meat in the meat sauce were so big that themeatballs were just a bonus... and so good! My wife had the angel hair pasta with pesto and shrimp. We wrapped it up with acannoli, which was exactly the amount of sweet we needed to finish up our dinner. The service was excellent as well. NOTE: Mywife's dish was much prettier when we first got it. She just started mixing before I could take a picture. Read more

Sam Hagler 3 years ago
5

We had a wonderful server named Lesley who made our dining experience very enjoyable and the food was just outstanding. ... Complements to the chef! The hostess was also very friendly. We were told seating would be about 25 minutes, but we only hadto wait maybe 10 minutes ????. The restaurant is very beautiful and the atmosphere is relaxing. Come for the food, though, andyou won't be disappointed. Got a pleasant surprise at how good the celery soup was, and I don't even like celery. A bit spicyfrom the datil pepper, but oh, so good. Everything in the pictures was great and provide an extra meal at home. Highlyrecommend this place when in the St. Augustine area of Florida. Read more