Reviews for Mama T’s Italian Eatery in Elkhorn, WI
I'm disappointed with how inconsistent Mama T's is. When the food is good, it's really good, but when it's bad, it's such a... waste of money. There have been numerous times that, for example, garlic bread has either been burnt or not cooked enough thatit has to be cooked when it's brought home, or the food is too salty/tastes off. Tonight though is just so disappointing. Thealfredo was room temperature and had the pasta water sitting in the bottom of take out container. Read more
Fantastic food and service was awesome. Had two or three ladies checking on us, chatted with us and gave reccomendations. Got... themeat Lasagna and meat tortellini, both came with fantastic garlic bread, and both were amazing but lasagna was hands down thefavorite. Will be coming here again and can't wait to try more off the menu! Read more
What a hidden gem. We have driven past it so many times and decided to try it tonight. I had the chicken Florentine, can I just... say that is one of the best Italian dishes I have ever had. My son and his friend had a pizza, holy cheese a lot!!!! That wasalso delicious and humorous watching them fight with the cheese. Try it, you will not be disappointed. Everyone is so niceespecially our server Emily. Read more
Great waitresses & great food. Lots to choose from and fair prices. I've heard friends rave about the tiramisu, but sadly we... were too full to try it. Definitely next time! Read more
Came in on a Wednesday evening around 7 pm and it was packed. We all got pastas(seafood, chicken, and spicy sausage). All of... them came with garlic bread and all of them very tasty. As far as pasta goes, it is as good as it can be except some dishes Ihad in Milan and Germany. Services was very friendly but a bit longer wait due to the crowd. Highly recommended and worth thewait. Read more
Talk about a home style restaurant that serves authentic Italian cuisine, this is the place. Don't let the location and size... fool you. Get out of your car and head on in. Lots of different sangria's as well! Read more
Had a great dinner here. Owner Laura and waitress Jennifer were both fantastic. Had shrimp fettuccine Alfredo and cheese ravioli... with pesto rosa sauce and breaded chicken. Both were delicious. Cute little Italian place. Definitely recommend! Read more
I generally don?t write reviews if food is good, but I would say this is just perfect and awesome not just food but the service,... price and wait time. Jennifer was my server, was nice, very polite and helped me choose my food. I had chicken cacciatore witharbitrator sauce and a cheesy garlic bread. Being an Indian, no language or accent issues, that?s additional plus point! Read more