Reviews for Don Carmelo’s Pizzeria in Elkhorn, NE

The pizza was perfect! This place does not skimp on the toppings. The order taker was friendly, the restaurant was very clean,... and did I mention the pizza was perfect? Read more

This place is simply an Omaha tradition. You are likely to find your favorite pizza place here. Truly unique and delicious. I am... a fan. Read more

My favorite cheese pizza in all of omaha. Traditional thin crust New York style pizza with quality ingredients

One of Omaha's best pizzas, IMO, but they're not the newest/latest/greatest so they often get overlooked.

Pizza, atmosphere, prices, & service are all top notch! Been eating their amazing food since I was a young adult at their... original location at 160th/Center. Outstanding EVERY SINGLE TIME! Keep doing what you?re doing! Read more

Consistently excellent pizza. Recently ordered a large quantity of pizza and appetizers for a party and everything was delicious... and ready on time. People raved about the pizza and wanted to know where we got it from. My mother (a native Italian) said itreminded her of the pizza in Italy (quite the compliment!) Read more

Terrible pizza, I?d rather have had a frozen pizza. Needed shark teeth to chew the crust, about 1 spoon full of sauce on a large... pizza, and very expensive for what you get. Also, About $.05 worth of ingredients on my $10 mini ?New York?s best?. Read more

The food was decent but seemed a little expensive for what I ordered - a medium pizza, ravioli (looked small as well), and... garlic bread totaled $40. Read more