Reviews for the cottonwood social in Elkhart Lake, WI

We had an awesome dinner at The Cottonwood Social. The drinks, food, and dessert were all delicious - and the service was... wonderful! One of the best dining views you can get in Wisconsin! Read more

We stopped in for a few cocktails and to watch the Packer game. The bartender had called in, however the rest of the staff was... very friendly, helpful and accommodating. What an amazing little gem hidden in Elkhart! A fireplace, jukebox, pool table,gaming machines, outdoor seating, beautiful views, this place has a little bit of everything for everyone. Will definitely bestopping back again sometime soon! Read more

I was here for a wedding this past weekend and don't get me wrong, this room is pretty with a beautiful view on the lake, but we... definitely ran into some issues. The room was very humid as they only had a window AC unit. According to a worker I overheard,their air system does not work. Our salad was put on the tables uncovered almost 2 hours before we were supposed to eat and thelettuce was wilted and slimy by that time. They served our dinner early which was lukewarm. We couldn't play pool due to missingballs. The jukebox was not set up ahead of time, so we spent awhile trying to get it working. Despite the issues we had, ourbartender, Alisa (I'm sorry if I spelt your name wrong), was very nice and and made our night more enjoyable!! :) Read more

We were there for a wedding this weekend and while the brides did a GORGEOUS job, the service was a bit subpar, ie. Dinner... started early and the food was lukewarm at best, salads were set out an hour early and we mushy by the time we sat down and theowners left early, which is unfortunate for their big day. It?s no secret though, that the bartender, Alisa absolutely made ournight!! She was fantastic and a breath of fresh air making our evening highly enjoyable, even when I called her by the wrongname more than once *facepalm* THANK YOU ALISA!!! Read more

They customized Veggie option for us which was not in the menu at all. Glad we got food that day. I appreciate the help of bar... tender for the special customized food. They delivered to the lake side. Friendly service. Great Views. Tasty Food. Everythingupto the mark. Read more

Great place on the lake. Outdoor seating suggested. Everyone is is very friendly and helpful . Service is slow. Expect... nearly 2 hours for dinner. But worth food is excellent. Take your time and enjoy.. Read more

Horrible Experience. The Old Fashioned cocktails we ordered were very average. Not sure if there was anyone working there that... was old enough to even make a drink. The ahi tuna wontons were so over soy sauced and over seasoned that they were hard to eat. Not to mention the totally average entrees and the one entree that gave me food poisoning. I was up all night with violentsickness for about 10-12 hours and it ruined my entire vacation. Do not order the chicken Marsala gnocchi. It tasted bad by myfirst forkful and I didn?t touch the rest of it. I?m so happy I didn?t eat the whole thing because I?d probably be in thehospital. Would not recommend. Bad service and worse food ???? Read more

Best burger and fries we have had. They call them truffle fries. Super attentive waiter and beautiful atmosphere! Best to make... reservations. Read more