Reviews for 523 Tap & Grill in Elkhart, IN
We stopped by the restaurant for dinner on Saturday night. Unfortunately all of the tables were booked so we ate at the bar... which worked out well. The bartender was friendly and took care of all of our needs. We had the Mac & Cheese with Chicken ($20)and the Vodka Penne with Chicken & Prosciutto ($18). The food was very good and the portion sizes were large. Parking wasconvenient in the parking lot next to the restaurant. Read more
Great food and service. Rachel was our server and made sure every request was accommodated. Everyone loved their meal. I had the... salmon (blackened) and really enjoyed it. Simple but delicious. Cannot say enough about Rachel?s charisma and taking ourexperience here to the next level. Definitely will come back! Read more
I'm going to break this review down because so much went so right and just a couple things were a bit off to hold back the five... star I love giving. Quickly though- wonderful location and atmosphere for an adult outing, great menu, awesome portions, fairprice. Staff ???????????????????? Super attentive staff who answered questions and made a great recommendation on the WhippedFeta app- absolutely delicious! Ambience ???????????????????? We really, really enjoyed the quiet space and no wait on Saturdayevening. Bathroom ???????????? (mostly clean but lights out always created a sketchy vibe) Menu ???????????????????? I alwaysenjoy reading through a creative menu and 523 has got it all whether you're looking for a salad or a soup or a steak or aslow-down-and-chat app! I wanted to try so many different things! Kitchen Execution ???????????? Plum Tasty Burger for me,ordered medium but received something not-quite-well done and hardly any plum sauce. I definitely enjoyed that goat cheesetopper though! Nearly-well for the peppered filet for my wife that was ordered at medium, and smothered in pretty much rawonions that she hadn't requested at all. Ultimately, I'd like to give 5????, but execution lacked tonight even if the conceptsare all *phenomenal* ideals. We will be back because this menu is SUPER creative for the area and we loved the quiet, sloweratmosphere so much. I honestly think 523 may have the vision to be a major downtown Main Street draw but the kitchen needs tonail the menu and approach every time for that to happen. Read more
Food was delicious. Flavorful. We had the grilled Brie and I would recommend that one to everyone. My husband had the sea bass... which was great! I had the ribeye with vegetables and the taste was awesome. The only thing I?d suggest is less herb butter ontop of the steak. There was way too much. Read more
This is an awesome place ? must stop again! Plum Tasty Burger is amazing! Desert is chocolate chip cookie pan?
This is an excellent restaurant. Not many places can get a filet well done without burning the outside. These guys did and it... is the best steak I've had in years. Everything was clean, staff was perfect. It was a little loud. But overall excellent! Read more
Great place! Our server Amber was great!! Very attentive! It appears everyone was willing to help. Great atmosphere! The food... was Da Bomb ???? I ordered the clam chowder which was chocked full of clam and potatoes. I also ordered the Saganaki (friedcheese) awesome! I also ordered a spicy shrimp dish which I couldn't enjoy. They fried the shrimp and then covered it with aspicy cream sauce. Unfortunately, while the shrimp was hot, the cream sauce was cold. So, I sent it back to get warmed up. Iordered a side of rice, when it came it was mushy???????????. Hope it reheats good!! (Shrimp not the rice) My friend orderedthe filet mignon which she said Melted In Her Mouth!!???? Read more
Went there last night 10/11/22 for my b-day with the kids. I am a foodie so I went crazy with the apps and such. All the food... was amazing. I would highly recommend this restaurant. We were all stuffed. I want the Portabella soup recipe. Service was greatas well. Make sure to go here!! Thank you for a wonderful dinner with my family. Read more