Reviews for Mario's Famous Pizza in Elizabeth, NJ
The only thing Mario is famous for is fishing the local marine life out of the polluted water next to the building and serving... it as ?chicken?. More like chicken of the sea sir. You ever see those 3 eyed fish from the Simpsons? Yea that?s basically what?son your buffalo chicken pizza. Read more
Should've gone with my 1st choice which was Penne w/vodka sauce and chicken. Ordered the chicken Parm sandwich with a side order... of pizza fries with the idea that I would take half of it for lunch the next day. Pizza fries were over saturated with a saltymarinara sauce which made the fries soggy & salty. Threw the entire thing away after 4 bites. Chicken Parm sandwich 2as ok butagain they used the same salty marinara sauce. Ate half of it and threw the rest out. Read more
Ate a personal pizza here a few days ago, and I'm still feeling it in my stomach. I love pizza but your pizza still got me ... nauseated. Too bad cuz visually it seemed like it'd be pretty tasty. Read more
This makes me miss living up top. I'm born and raised in NY but live in Atlanta. This brought me back to my childhood. Not just... the food, but the neighborhood love. They greeted everyone that walked through the door as family. Personal greetings as if theywere all best friends. My wife sat in awe. Now to the food. We only got the basics... Slices of pizza and garlic knots. Maaaaaanthe best marinara sauce I've ever tasted. I got the chicken bacon ranch and Philly cheese steak pizza.. Magnificent! My wife gotan all white slice and Pepperoni! We were in heaven. The staff is lovely and I can see why they have lasted over 40 yrs! I missNY/NJ so much. Thank you Mario's Pizzeria for bringing me back to my childhood! Read more
Fantastic food, great hospitality, and the prices are unbelievable. The garlic bread was phenomenal and my spaghetti and sausage... was top shelf. Highly recommend. Read more
Nice local joint I found near my hotel. Parking is on the street or in the park across the street (I'm not local check parking... rules before you leave your car). Staff super nice and food comes fast. I ordered chicken parm with spaghetti the pasta wascooked perfectly, chicken nice and juicy & the sauce had lots of flavor. The neighborhood might look a little sketchy to peoplecoming from outside the state, but I found the people around there very friendly. Read more
Order a Sicilian 16" pepperoni pizza. It was amazing! Crust was thick and crusty. Cheese had right amount of brown. Had spots of... sauce on top which was good. Right amount of saltiness. I would definitely come back. Thank you! Excellent service. Read more
I came here for a quick pizza for my kids on the way thru town. I saw Mario reach his hand into the pot of sauce and hand... slathered in into my pizza. He used his other hand that he sneezed into to grab the "cheese" which I thought was tofu anddumped half on the counter and half the pizza. Dough was undercooked. Saw a guy serve divorce papers on my way out. Propsto that guy. He chose a great spot! Read more