Reviews for Hall of Fame Pizza & Wings in Eldridge, IA

Tried to order with phone. After repeating the order several times finally got tried to pay. That did not go well $80+ order had... to just say cancle we will get something else. Almost like they didnt want the business... Read more

Good pizza! Service was good and it isn't crazy expensive for a local pizza joint. Wish prices were a tad lower, but I didn't... have any issues with my food at all! Read more

Stay away!!! Dewitt location is amazing, this location nickel and dimes you for everything just because it?s ?Eldridge? not even... close to enough sauce on the wings, help will give your food to someone else and then hand it to you after they bring it back. Read more

LOVE their pizza! You'll be full after a couple slices! Well worth the $$. Their garlic parm sauce is the best ever! They should... seriously bottle it & sell it. If probably be their #1 purchaser. Lol Good food, good prices for the quality Read more

Nice to have another place in town that sells pizza by the slice but the cheese usually sticks to the paper box it comes in... which is weird because it's not very hot. And its a little disappointing when you open the box and the slice is a lot smallerthan expected, but for 2.50 its not a bad deal. I'll keep getting the pizza by the slice for as long as they continue to do it. Read more

Got a 16 inch half cheese half pepperoni and a cheesebread. Was 32 dollars. Same price as uncle bills etc. Better than fast food... pizza, and different than "quad cities style". The slices are big and the hand-tossed crust is good and not super flimsy. Theyalso sell pizza by the slice during the week and have a drive-thru so thats nice. I wish they gave out coupons or menus. Read more

Very rude place to order food. We have had nothing but problems with this place. Will NOT replace food or give money back. Not... happy at all. They do not take blame for NOTHING!! I MANAGEMENT is just as bad. I spend anywhere from 40 to 80 dollars when weorder from this establishment. No more. I will take my business elsewhere. Im sure other establishment will LOVE to get ourmoney!! Food was barely warm when we got it tonight. It doesn't do any good to complain. I had to warm it in the microwave justto get it hot enough so I could est it. The chips were stale beyond stale. Pay too much for food to be like this. I would havebeen better off to make it myself!! The rate they are going they will be going under as well. Pizza joints do not last long herein ELDRIDGE!! Because they do not care about the product all they want is your $$. Read more

The pizza and boneless wings were great! I ordered with sauce on the side, just like I do at bdubs. I thought their wings and... sauces were on par or better than bdubs. Got the kicker and Hawaiian pizza. Really tasty. The delivery driver was nicetoo! Nothing negative to say. I'd recommend Hall of Fame in a heartbeat. Read more