Reviews for Carrington in Egg Harbor, WI
We showed up on a Saturday around 645pm without a reservation (party of 4 adults) and were told the wait would be an hour. We... were fine with that and got a drink at the bar. The bartender was fantastic. The hostess had a bit of an attitude. We got seatedan hour later and ordered our food right away. An hour later our food arrived. It was warm and good but very late. Therestaurant was not very busy. We would have gotten dessert but we?re sick of waiting so long we paid and left. Not sure id beback considering how long it took to get the food. Come with the intent of finishing a few good drinks before you arrive oryou?ll get bored (and hungry) waiting so long. Read more
Our favorite Door County dining experience. Amazing views. Have dinner during sunset and it will be a perfect end to your day.... We love the staff they bring in each summer. Very personable. You need to dine here! Read more
Ignore the haters. Likely they are from Illinois and impatient after their long drive from hell to paradise. 5 star cherry BBQ... ribs, succulent lobster, fantastic ribeye and the DC new fashioned and DC side car drinks were incredible. Oh, and the servicewas great. Let the haters hate! Read more
The food was great cherry barbecued ribs, broiled haddock, walleye and cherry barbecue glazed salmon. One if not the best... settings in Door County! We were served in a timely fashion. It was an enjoyable dining experience! Read more
Food was fantastic. Our waitress was outstanding and the view from our outdoor table was spectacular.
Really got the feeling that this place had just hired summer help and threw them to the wolves without proper training. A few of... the employees didn't seem like they knew what they were supposed to do and didn't always have someone else around to supportthem. Arrived at 6:15 and despite at least half the tables in the place being empty they said they couldn't seat us until 7:45.No big deal we know some places are understaffed and maybe have COVID protocols for seating so we waited at the bar and had adrink. When 7:45 rolls around I go to the hostess to ask if our table is ready. There were three employees there, it seemedlike two new people who were confused about where to put us and one experienced employee who seemed annoyed that she had tohelp. They sort of discussed/bickered at each other a bit before figuring out where they would put us. The whole thing justreally made it feel like we were a big inconvenience for them. Soon after that we get seated and put in our orders with thewaitress. It seemed pretty clear that the waitress was frustrated with her newer coworkers and she even made a comment about itwhich made us feel a bit uncomfortable. Again it just kind of felt like serving us was an inconvenience which is not a goodfeeling as a customer. We put in our orders a burger for myself and fish and chips for my wife. It took about 45 minutes for thefood to come out during which time the waitress did not come back and check on us at all. At one point I just went to the barfor another drink and a water for my wife. When the food arrives my wife's fish and chips were fine but my burger was well doneand a little burnt despite them making a point to ask me how I wanted it cooked and asking for medium. The fries were also sortof just soggy. It felt like they just threw some frozen fries in the oven just long enough for them to thaw and be sort ofwarm. There definitely were some positives. Their cocktails were pretty good and their location has an am Read more
The Carrington Door County (previously The Carrington Pub & Grill) has long been a favorite place to dine. They have a good... variety of dishes on their menu from the appetizers, to deserts steak, hamburgers, salads, pasta dishes, a great fish fry, (Ienjoy the baked haddock) and much more. I've always been very satisfied and filled with their dishes. Their staff in the peakseason is fabulous with their professional and attentive service. Off season is a little more laid back, and I'll admit I enjoythe summer help more, but this will always be our go to place of choice. The atmosphere is welcoming with a double sidedfireplace as you enter the building and tables on its flipside in the main dining area to enjoy the ambiance and warmth whileyou dine. There is a full bar and they occasionally have live entertainment and in the winter months karaoke for all you risingstars ???? They offer inside as well as outside dining that offers a view of the tranquil grounds of the Landmark Resort and ofcourse the lake with spectacular DC sunsets. In cooler months they have the patio heaters throughout the outside diningarea. Overall I highly recommend checking out the Carrington Door County. See you next time! Read more
Good place, great view from the dining room. Old Fashions were well made. I had the ribs and my wife had the baked haddock both... were good. Flourless chocolate torte cake was delicious. Staff was friendly and attentive. Our food was brought out in areasonable amount of time and was hot. Seen lots of negative reviews on this place but we had nothing but a positiveexperience. If I had anything negative it was that the food is a little pricey for what you get, but these days what's not?Overall I recommend and would return to try more items on the menu given the chance. Read more