Reviews for 45th Street Pub in Edgewater Park, NJ
This was my first time visiting. I was not impressed at all. The atmosphere was not inviting, and the staff member at the door... checking IDs was not friendly. It wasn't a place where I was able to enjoy the vibe. On a positive note, I had the shrimp tacos,which were very good. Read more
I used to love this place, but I will NOT be back. They changed to a no service place. You have to go to a service area at the... bar to wait for and order drinks. Which is annoying, but it sucks because the bartenders are also tending to the rest of the bartoo. Not to mention that the bar tenders are a bit slow and not very excited to be working there. The entire experience was justnot at all what I was expecting and am soo sad because there isn't much else in town to do. Read more
Always great food and great staff. The atmosphere is a bar setting with a back room if you have a party. It?s right off of 130... so convenient. The access is sketchy there was an accident with someone trying to enter the establishment so be careful. Thefries are just regular, I mainly go there for the wings. They are larger than BWW and are fresh. No matter the time of day it?sa great place to just stop by. Read more
Pizza sucks and they are not family friendly during dinner hours as they do not allow children after 7pm. I think this is... extremely unreasonable as they have plenty of dedicated space between the bar and tables. I could understand if it was a latertime like 10 or after but people don?t have dinner before 7pm. Read more
I have been to this Pub twice and each time I enjoyed myself. Great atmosphere, great food, great drinks (I like whiskey sours... with cherries, also vodka and cranberry juice). Great food menu and great employees! They didn't have a band playing that night.One of the employees was a guy I worked with some years at a different job. A very nice person! My friends and I plan on goingback soon (once or twice a month). Check it out!! You will have a great time!!! Update - went to the 45th Street Pub thisevening & again had a great time. Nice atmosphere & great food & drinks. Their drinks r awesome & the food is too. Customerservice is very good! U will have very nice time there. Check them out!! Read more
First time here and I had great service, our waitress was lyric ( I apologize in advance not sure how her name is spelled) but... she was a fantastic waitress I would definitely go back and the food was great. I would recommend anyone to come visit thisplace Read more
The waitress was great, but the food was trash. Normally, the food is solid, but not tonight. Maybe it was a bad night, or... maybe the janitor was cooking, with mittens on... I ordered the 45th street burger, medium rare, with grilled onions and a sidesalad. What I got was a charbroiled, extra well done, freezer burned hockey with 3 mushrooms, no onions and extra salty fries, that would make Lot's wife jealous... and a side salad. The only reason I received the side salad was because the waitress,Suzanne, caught the error. My dog had a fantastic dinner, but after the fires, he looks like he needs an IV torehydrate. Pictures of food and receipt included. The only reason I didn't take it back and raise hell, was the fact that myServer, Suzanne was awesome. I would say demote the cook to janitor, but that would be an insult to janitors worldwide. Ugh Read more
I thought this Pub was a fun, inclusive place to enjoy a drink and eat a nice meal, and I quickly learned that is not the case.... The menu consists of overpriced food which is likely to come out to you either under or overcooked - and if you have the wings,possibly even pink. The "chefs" don't seem to care much about the quality of food they're serving. Management frequently feelsintimidated when the restaurant has too many people of color who they do not "recognize" and will often tell security to lockthe door and not allow anyone else in. The bartenders will frequently skip over guests who are waiting to be served and giveattitudes often. Undercooked food, poor service and racist management - it's a shame. Read more