Reviews for Bettini Restaurant in Edgartown, MA

The ambiance and service was excellent. I am giving it a 3 because the pasta portion size was equal to a side of pasta. We... ordered the pork pappardelle and I'm not kidding when I say it was less than a kid's portion. We don't like large portionseither because we appreciate a serving amount that's enough to almost make you full, but not completely. The pasta also lacked aflavorful sauce, definitely not worth the money. I'd recommend going for a drink and an appetizer, which will be $50, but you'llexperience an incredible view and wonderful service. Read more

Excellent experience from pleasant hostess greeting to finish, with the very best and most considerate attention from our... graceful server Caroline. Endive salad, lobster ravioli, heirloom tomato salad, and pork pappardelle ordered at our table andall perfectly balanced and delicious. Perfect portions. The wine list and their new wine room were impressive. Manager made therounds to insure patrons were happy. Comfortable seating and nice ambiance. A perfect dining experience! Read more

Though we had to wait 30 minutes for our table it was well worth the wait. My husband on his big birthday had what he described... as the best tuna he has eaten. My meal was delicious and though we were too full for dessert they brought as a bagged delicioustreat from the pastry chef. The waiter was delightful and we enjoyed every minute of it! Read more

The atmosphere is amazing, however it is very loud. The appetizers to start were very good. We had the clam chowder and gazpacho... which the gazpacho was one of the best i've had. However, once the entrees came after some time it was clear that sometimes thestart is better than the finish. The entrees were overly creamy, almost as if they were trying to hide the lack of flavor withcream. The dish portions are extremely small, and overall the taste is not worth the very expensive price of them. Read more

Always a winner! This place is amazing. I had the striped which was crunchy on the outside and tender on the inside with fresh... corn and shrimp. The side of broccolini was tender and flavorful, really tasty. The chicken, Believe it or not, what is the starof the show. So crunchy on the outside and tender on the inside, with the taste of Thanksgiving dinner underneath the chicken.Really a showstopper. We shared lobster ravioli for an appetizer which was equally delicious. This place is not to be missed! IfI had one complaint, it would be that I listed a birthday celebration at the reservation time, and it was not recognized. Thisis easily overlooked because of the deliciousness of the meal. Read more

Wedding anniversary celebration dinner. Everything was terrific and memorable. We were warmly greeted and each staff member was... aware that we were there for our anniversary and extended their well wishes. Our meal was excellent including the best clamchowder that either of us have ever had. My wife had a delicious fluke meal and I had an exceptional veal chop. If we were notso full, there were several outstanding dessert choices - next time! Even as we left, the hostess made sure to congratulate usand asked to be sure that we were happy. We certainly were. Read more

My husband and I recently visited the Harbor View Hotel for NYE and we had the loveliest time!!! The hotel is perfectly located... just steps from downtown Edgartown so we were able to walk everywhere and take in the sights. Our room had an amazing view ofEdgartown Lighthouse and the ocean! Everything was top notch, this was our second time staying at the hotel and we are alreadyplanning when we can come back this summer. Also, the staff is so professional and helpful, we were really impressed the entiretime! We dined at Bettini for NYE and it was the perfect way to ring in the new year. We started with the burrata and thecalamari, then moved onto some of their fresh pastas and finished with a few main course and it was just perfection. We lovedevery bite and the service was fab! Read more

I had an excellent experience at Bettini. The food was delicious, and the service was outstanding. The pace of delivery of... each course was spot on, and our waiter was experienced, had great humor, and was incredibly respectful and responsive. Read more