Reviews for 19 Prime Cast Iron Steakhouse in Edgartown, MA

Wagyu flat iron steak was delicious. I was surprised at how flavorful and tender the cut was. Lobster tail was incredibly... tender and not too fishy. Also had the loaded potato that was soo big I couldn't finish it. And I always finish my meals. Topnotch service and great ambiance on the back deck. Read more

Best steak I've ever had we ordered it all and it was fantastic

Spendy but worth it. Octopus and tuna poke were especially tasty. And for the steaks go with the port wine sauce addition.

This place is absolutely fantastic. Food is exceptional. Service was outstanding. Interior is gorgeous. Bathrooms are pristine.... 10/10. Read more

Best restaurant in Edgartown if not all of Martha's Vineyard! Great service, great atmosphere and the food is incredible! Every... single time I go here it just gets better and better! You can't go wrong with anything on the menu but my all-time faves are thefilet mignon, dauphinoise potatoes and the creamed corn! My go-to order! Joe, the owner and head chef always comes out to makesure his guests are enjoying themselves...and he's the nicest person! You truly feel like you're part of the family. Don't missthis place!! You won't regret it. Read more

Great service and great food. Ana and those who served our large wedding party were the absolute best.

My Husband and Is just enjoyed an amazing dinner. We had the charred octopus which was accompanied by roasted potatoes, capers... and a delicious sauce. We shared the Cowboy Steak and it was perfectly prepared and seasoned well. We had the brussel sproutsand Mac and cheese. Each dish was full of flavor and they remained warm in small cast iron skillets. The atmosphere was livelyand the restaurant was nicely appointed. There are no large tables on the interior but there were accommodations for largerparties outdoors. It was a chilly evening and they were prepared with heat lamps. The service was very good. My Husband waspleasingly surprised they offered his favorite bourbon ?Blanton?s?. We will be back again! A great spot for Date night. Hats offto the chef. Read more

Perfect last night dinner on Martha?s Vineyard. Excellent drinks and great recommendations from staff on oysters and other... selections. Cowboy steak, sea bass, oysters on the half shell, clam chowder and grilled octopus was excellent. Read more